It would seem HID is dead.

Enderman will build another Zooka :laughing:

Thanks :slight_smile:
It’s expensive though, like $500+ usually, which I could put towards my next flashlight project.
On top of that, it is like 1.5x more expensive for me thanks to the canadian dollar xD

Certainly, I will not stop until I have a non-bulb flashlight that can beat all of those short arc lights on that graph :wink:

Well I guess you’re gonna need some serious XXXL aspherics for that… Good luck :+1:

Not this time, it will be reflector only :smiley: and thank you

I made an ‘invention’ for a reflector LED light:

“Wavien dome”

The dome will have to be attached to the glass lens

Pretty similar to the design often used for short arc lamps:

Compared to a lens+wavien collar of the same diameter it will have less lux though, since the lens won’t have the dead spot in the middle.
The lens will also give a tighter beam since all of the points on the surface will be at a longer distance from the LED.

Thanks but no thanks, I don’t really want to cosplay as Captain Toad.

Sure, but it would be fun (difficult fun) to try on the GT for example.
No more spill and a bit more beam.

Yup.

Wait…I must have missed that memo about hid’s getting phased out. :person_facepalming:

Hmm, what’s the “texture” on the front lens of the Polarion?

It’s a factory diffuser. It just clips in the grooves of the bezel ring. They work amazingly.
I call the diffused light from this a big ol ball of cotton beam, removes the hotspot completely.

Recently saw this Czech company, they make 4 models all HID, top one -> throw 4 kilometers…

hid has advantages on throw, but in many situation a sililar sized light like the BLF GT with LED is more useful

Awesome shot. HID not worth it anymore imho

Does the Title of this topic still hold true? Have LED tech advanced where HID is being forgotten?

I ask cause I don’t have any HID lights and would be interested to have one. what are the major brands out there?

Is this headlamp stable?

I doubt it. LEDs are nowhere close to the luminance for the size of the light source as HID, though LED is likely far better when a wider view of illumination is needed. A few marine large searchlight makers use both now for both spot and flood.

Just saw this thread and i had to stop by. They are less in use due to AWWW LED’s these days but i spoke with some high end torch makers they start thinking about drivers similar to AW and AlanB regulators. I don’t have any HID but i do have dozen incan mods from 1x16340 up to 8x18650 versions.
My latest build is CPF Fivemega Elephant II with 3” head and AlanB regulator which will run Osram 64657 bulb (250W - 11000lm).
Don’t have pictures but i’ll be happy to post after i get home from a trip.

Yes. Pictures.