[Canceled] Sofirn SP70 BLF Edition

DB Custom already mentioned a good point about C8G. Unless xhp35 is driven to max it doesn’t out throw a Fet xplhi. So you will get a wider hot spot, better regulation and worse throw. Which might still be worth it depending on what you need

Definitely am interested in seeing how this light turns out, but have 2 questions:

1) is the goal with the driver to achieve solid regulated output, or to simply achieve the max lumens possible? Personally I prefer a good boost driver as opposed to fet.

2) any idea how long it will take the details for this light to be finalized and then ready to order? Weeks, months, hopefully not years, etc.

thanks!

1) --> see the OP:

  • High yield MOSFET/FET (Infineon) for better output

This means a similar driver design, not boost. Regulated boost drivers at reasonable costs can't do high amps, so as said before, you may get 3500-4000 lumens at most as opposed to 8000+. Boost drivers require more advanced drivers, proper electronic design work, more $$$ parts, more risks, more testing, etc. Wuben T70 is a good example of a decent quality single cell boost XHP70.2 light that can get just over 4000 lumens, and you pay for that driver and all the R&D that went into it.

2) yeah, somewhere between weeks and years ( - ok, I have no idea, not sure anyone does). All the past projects take longer than expected and typically are very unpredictable, but this one at least has a good start with some easy-to-achieve goals, comparatively with other projects, if we stay with a known driver design we know will run the firmware we want and drive this light.

I'm actually quite interested in the (probable) linear regulator that was pointed out on the SP70's driver. If the enthusiast community came across a good linear regulator that was designed for 6V+ instead of just abusing 7135s, that would be nice.

Also, I wouldn't oppose a price increase on the BLF version. Currently to get what I want, I have to mod an SP70 or L6. The SP70 would require spring bypasses and a new driver, at the very least, for me to be happy, and the same goes for the XHP70.2 L6. That still puts the price at/above $60, and that's if I don't replace the lens with AR or change the LED, or change the switch LEDs (for the L6, add them).

Yep, I totally agree bout dumping the 7135's we dump on. They are continuously a problem - no true specs (obsoleted years ago, clones are undocumented), and we run them at higher voltages, etc. TA has a solution though using resistors, but we in general lack an understanding of the regulators, or other options., for example, for they would handle out high PWM rates and can we get low moon level output, etc.

LED4Power has been doing this for a long time, even with 6V

Tom E, you’re not the first I hear complaining about 7135s.

I wonder…could we as a community move on to some other solution?
I don’t mean specifically in this light. I mean some future generation of a standard BLF driver.

FET based drivers are said to be hard to do well. Though Lexel works on one now, he may succeed with it.
There are other stock regulators that we could choose though. F.e. Mike C, moderator007 have tried some powerful current-adjustable regulators, gchart played with non-adjustable as well.
That Mike C confugurations look like they would give most of the benefits of a FET based regulator while being much easier to implement.

sofirn can purchase 4800mAh 21700 batteries which was from tesla.

I think they will be good to push the limit of XHP70.2 led

These are very good batteries but they are a moderate discharge model so they won’t push the LED to the limit.

Take note that the positive poles on these cells are sunken, they won’t make contact in series unless you add a button top. Which is problematic because the positive poles are aluminium.

Does this mean the BLF edition will be 2x21700? Does Sofirn have an estimated time of arrival?

I'm a bit confused about those 4.800mAh. Barry are you sure these come from Tesla? Can you please check if these cells are the original Sanyo NCR21700A 5.000mAh? These are also sold by Vapcell as Vapcell INR21700 5000mAh, see HKJ's test here: https://budgetlightforum.com/t/-/54274

I agree with Agro that this battery is not considered as a classic high drain battery but a very good compromise between capacity and intermediate power drain (< 15A). Please have a look onto this comparison between this "Tesla battery" and the PLB-55A cell (to be found in Shockli IMR26650 5.500mAh or Keeppower 6.000mAh). As you can see there is no benefit in using the 21700 Tesla battery but only disadvantages due to less capacity and the need for an additional conductor between both batteries which again increases contact resistance and subsequently leads to additional voltage drop.

If you want to run the SP70 with maximum output, Samsung's 30T and 40T as well as Molicel's P42A are the best high drain batteries.

However, if Sofirn chose to offer the "Tesla battery" separately or in combination with C8G, it would be an intruiging option. :-)

Sofirn, read this. Don’t waste your time with Tesla battery. Too many problems and other good batteries are easy to source. If you were experienced battery company then maybe.

the batteries from Tesla were made by Panasonic 5000mAh

I didn’t know they are not good enough as HD batteries

Barry, please can you try to get in touch with Power Long Battery Technology Co. Ltd in Dongguan, China?

https://www.powerlongbattery.com/about-us

They offer the best 26650 batteries available so far. If Sofirn were able to source PLB-55A cells it would be really great. These cells provide more power than Sofirn's new 26650 HD cells.

If you want to go for 21700 batteries (personally, I'd really appreciate this approach), please try to get cells like Molicel P42A or Samsung 40T for these should have the best compromise between high drain (> 15A) and capacity. Samsung's 30T would not make much sense for it has not much capacity and its benefit over the 40T would only last some seconds with a fresh, fully charged cell.

Something interesting that caught my attention this morning...

https://budgetlightforum.com/t/-/56868

So, there actually is a custom version of Andúril that supports both e-switch and the tailclicky forward switch. If we want to have Andúril on Sofirn's SP70 BLF edition, this custom version might be the right thing as flashing the standard Andúril would normally sacrifice the momentary turbo and mode memory function of the tailclicky. Maybe Toykeeper can share with us her thoughts about it. ;-)

Yes, more Anduril please!

Just good a quick and helpful answer from Toykeeper that I would like to include here:

will contact them. Is there any test of their batteries?

That's great news. I'm sure many customers will be interested in buying these cells (maybe even more if offered on Amazon US/AU/DE, too).

As a reference, please have a look onto Henrik's review of the Shockli IMR26650 5500mAh which uses the PLB-55A cell from Power Long Battery.

For my super high amp 6V lights, I've converted over to only FET. The smooth ramping is a little jumpy at the low levels, but at least works. I can fry a 7135 in seconds on those lights. Sorry, haven't kept up with the new designs, but very interested in these alternate solutions. Of course what I want is smooth ramping capability on these other designs, and smooth transition to the full FET. Of course high PWM is a must, and no PWM preferred.