Noctigon K1 info / review

Is the K1 stock Dale?

Yup, one of few such in my possession…

Very nice…

I’m guessing my measurements are low because the sensor wasn’t far enough away for a proper reading. IIRC, I measured it at only 5 meters, which probably isn’t a long enough shot for this type of thrower.

A 30 meter test sounds much more effective.

I first tested mine at 5M as well, it was in the lower 600’s and impressive enough to make me leave it alone, the longer 30M test is likely more appropriate for a thrower, as you say. I was setting up for the truly big boys and included the K1 on a hunch. :smiley:

(The big boys pretty much annihilated it by the way. The SBT-90.2 is for real! 4860 lumens doing 1.863Mcd)

To it’s credit though, I carried the K1 in the pocket of my sweat pants when going outside for this test. Impressive beyond words when looking at it’s competitors…

Honestly I want a K1 more and more, I just want to know if Vinh can up these a decent amount….

Not much of a way to up the performance in these, they’re running at max levels as they are. Now, significant changes could yield some good results and I’ll probably investigate this further… should have a 90.2 to play with this week. Depends on what your acceptable performance parameters look like, we all have varying expectations…

I’ve been a flashlight enthusiast for over twenty years - all the way from Wayne at Elektrolumens, to Wayne at Skylumens. I remember how psyched we were to hear the first rumors that Luxeon might soon be releasing a new emitter that was going to put out a whopping 70 lumens - almost twice what a 3D Maglite could do. :smiley:

And if I’m being perfectly honest, the older I get, the more I’ve come to despise these uber complex, multi-layered torch UIs. I’ve had my new K1 for all of about 12 hours and probably actually used it for only about 120 seconds. I’ve done nothing more than turn it on, ramp up brightness, ramp down brightness and turn it off. Yet on the 20 minute drive between home and work - in its holster, inside a backpack - the light somehow managed to reprogram itself into a mode where it wouldn’t go above maybe 50% brightness. Two minutes of use and I’ve already got one factory reset under my belt. Thank God this forum exists or I wouldn’t have figured out that much. And I’m by no means singling out this otherwise very impressive light. I’ve got a BLF GT Micro that’s almost completely worthless. It will only turn on in turbo mode and then immediately go into thermal regulation. All attempts at a reset have failed miserably.

If anyone out there is listening, I have to believe there’s still a market for offering a bare bones, no frills UI option with these lights. Turn on, ramp through the full range of brightnesses and turn off. That’s it. No strobes. No beacons. No SOS. No choices between stepped and continuous ramping. No reprogramming thermal step down points. No adjusting button colors. Just light. Call it the “Curmudgeon UI”. I won’t be offended.

Having all these options was fun at one point. But now I’m at a stage where I can appreciate a flashlight that’s less complicated than a space shuttle launch. I had actually bought this light with the intention of gifting it to my cousin who’s far less of a flashlight maven than anyone posting here. I don’t know how I can do that now, given my own two minute track record. Again, I’m not saying to keep these complex UIs from the people who appreciate and get excited for them. By all means, program away. Just please consider offering an opt out package for the ‘less is more’ contingent.

Thank you. :wink:

TBH I’m between.
I modified Andruil for my own use and the most important change was deletion of all the stuff I don’t use. There was a lot of it.
Sometimes wish there was not just advanced-mode and muggle-mode but also some (default) mode in between. Simple ramping with shortcuts and not much more.

I feel the same. Specially when giving the light to somebody who doesnt know it. I got a one mode c8 for that purpose.

Four clicks- lockout…. no accidental button issues.

I do see your point, my memory is horrible and too much by way of options gets lost on me. That said, Anduril is my favorite UI and I use it in every light I possibly can.

I reduced that to 3 clicks in mine. Perfectly safe and significantly easier to use.

I added a number of changes related to lockout…

  • 3 clicks unlock turns the light on
  • 3 clicks-hold unlock turns the light on at moonlight and starts ramping up
  • 3 clicks from either off or on locks the light out
  • When power is connected the light starts locked out rather than off
  • the light automatically goes from off to lockout after 10 minutes of inactivity
  • AUX LEDs are bright when off but dim when locked out, so I can immediately tell what mode I’m in

It works WAY better than stock for me.

:+1: :+1: :+1:

You hit the nail on the head, Dale. It’s not just that these UIs are complex, it’s also that there are now so many of them. I have these five lights that use Andúril. Those four use VNX3. This pile here uses Emisar D4. The ones over there use VNX4. All very capable and well thought out UIs, no doubt. Their creators deserve tremendous praise. But I’ve simply lost the desire to master them because I personally have no compelling use case for 99% of what they have to offer.

If nothing else, perhaps we could at least convince these UI designers to come up with interfaces that make it near impossible to get into any programming mode accidentally. I actually love having the ability to custom set my moonlight mode very low. I think the first light I can remember giving me that capability required that I quickly twist the tail cap on and off something like twelve times to enter programming mode. That I can live with, and/or gift with confidence, because I know there’s no way the light could unintentionally enter such a mode in the field. But having a light that can accidentally reprogram itself just by dropping it in its holster the wrong way is unacceptable.

Anyway, thanks to all who’ve commented for your understanding. I wasn’t quite sure what might await me when I reopened this thread this morning, but I’m very relieved to see that my comments are being received in the spirit I intended them. It’s certainly not my intent to offend any who are responsible for these UIs. You are all far smarter than I am. :slight_smile: But perhaps a little constructive criticism could result in future interfaces that have enhanced value to all users, regardless of their use case.

Broke down and sprung for one.

Anyone care to weigh in on going with a W1 or W2?

Planning on getting one eventually, and I’m leaning towards the W2. Given the larger emitter surface, the beam should be a little broader than the W1 at the expense of total throw, correct? I understand it’s 100,000CD less than the W1 and a higher lumen output, I’m primarily interested in a slightly less laser-like beam pattern that the W1 is capable of.

I’d say your analysis is pretty much spot on.

Well... if you decide it's not for you I'll buy itfrom you... I'm looking for an Anduril thrower in a hurry because I need a daytime strobe for oblivious drivers while I'm walking dogs. Almost got whacked out again today on a walk. And the Anduril options are great because of the customizing I can do with strobe. And no, I can't wait for China shipping.

I come from the heady days of the early 2000's myself... Elektrolumens, Mr Bulk, all the great modders.

do you need a 1500 meter thrower to walk the dog?!?

pencil beam??

I’d get a 1000 lumen floody head lamp myself

I find the best dog walking kit is a floody headlamp as you say and a pocketable thrower to see things in the distance. (Emisar D1 is my choice, but previously I carried a Convoy C8.) The Noctigon K1 seems just a bit too large for the pocket - and more thrower than I would ever need for the purpose.

More lights = win. No argument here