This is all flashlights, spotlights, duty lights, modded lights, etc. Don't include what you have coming, just what you have at the moment, and not what you've given away, either.
Mine...
1) Stanley 1,365 lumen spotlight
2) UF 980L
3) Kegos KE-5
4) KD p60 3-18 volt xm-l one-mode dropin
5) Manafont UF C8 XM-L - tie with - KD UF C8
12 volt incan spotlight
F15 modded to 3.5 amps by E1320
Solarforce L2 with Manafont T6 3 mode
Balder SE-1 XML
501a with E1320 modded XPG
1. DRY CW turbo
2. Fenix TK-70
3. Fandyfire triple xml modded
4. DRY NW turbo
5. Fenix TK-60
We are talking about the hotspot brightness, correct?
1. Small Sun ZY-C10-S (on throw)
2. Keygos KE-5 (arrived today, and wow!)
3. DRY NW
...
x. Ultrafire V6-T60
y. Keygos M12
The rest is not even to be mentioned in this context. :)
Edit:
I forgot the DRY. It's not a thrower (is what made me forget it), but still *mighty* bright.
Edit2:
Swapped 1 and 2, SS ZY-C10-S is brighter.
I see now that you meant overall brightness. DRY without anything even remotely close to compete with it.
Uniquefire 3900 3XM-L
Solarforce M8
Shadow JM07 Pro
Solarforce L2P with MF 3 mode drop-in
Solarforce M6
Zebralight SC600
Skyray STL-V2
UF2100
2 P60 XMLs
Dry CW
UltraFire UF-980L
E1320/UltraFire MCU-C88
E1320/TrustFire F15-T6
Solarforce L2P/3-mode UltraFire XM-L (sku 5720)
Funny how many times E gets in there.
Foy
Professionals Favorite Halogen spotlight
Dereelight DBS-T
Crelant 7G5
Olight M3X
Sunwayman T40CS or Fenix TK41
100W HID homebrew mega-spotlight
Trustfire TR-J12
Wolf-Eyes Boxer 24W
SkyRay 3800
5th place is a toss up between several single LED lights
55w HID DIY
Stanley HID
Xtar D30
55W incan
I am not sure which of these 2 is brighter.... Ultrafire HD2010 or MAG-Eneloop 1185
MAG-1185 is the big one on top
ebay hid flashlight
dry NW (no turbo mode)
kd C8
Sipik SK68
generic 'cree' flashlight
Ultrafire C8 XML (ebay 365 bid) great quality and my brightest torch
Trustfire TF-R2 fitted with a 3 mode manafont XML P60
Ultrafire 504b with a MCE dropin
Uniquefire G10
Uniquefire S10
My R5 drop ins may have made it in the list but this is the order from memory.
No, overall brightness.
I should send you an XML U2 drop in for your L2P and I can make the list again.
By Lumen output or Hotspot intensity?
1. (Hotspot) - Modded aspheric 3D Maglite with hard-driven XR-E
(These next three are in no particular order)
2. Reasonably-driven TR-1200 with 5x XR-E emitters
3. Ultrafire WF 504b with MF 3-mode XM-L dropin
4. eBay-purchased deep-reflector C8-clone (I think this one has a poor bin on the LED since it doesn't seem to have as bright a hotspot as other C8s I've had)
5.Modded 3D Maglite with 3x XR-E R2 emitters
1) Modded 3*XM-L U2 FandyFire STL-V2 w/ 4x 18650's (estimated >2000 lm)
2) Solarforce L2P with Manafont UF 3-mode XM-L drop-in (800 lm)
3) DX UltraFire 504B (500 lm)
4) JetBeam PA40NW (450 lm)
5) Klarus P2A (250 lm)
1. Modded Beamtech Triple XML
2. Sky Ray G6 XML SS(3.5A)
3. SF C2 with 3A NW dropin
4. Trustfire X9 w/2.8A driver
5. Keygos KE5 WW w/ 2.8A driver
I have only Led flashlights, no Hid, so if max brightness is the goal, and it doesn't matter if flood or throw, my list could be:
1- Dry CW
2- Dry NW
3- all them together, in no particular order, V60C, SR51, 7G5, TK35. All them use XM-L and in real world use there's not a ton of difference between them in brightness. Throw to flood their order would be 7G5, V60C, SR51, TK35.
4- C8 (Ultrafire host and reflector with KD XM-L Nanjg105 pill)
5- TK21
I cheated and listed more than 5, I know... 
All DIY stuff:
180,000 lumen using 12xBridgelux arrays @ 150W each
100,000 lumen 7xBridgelux arrays
50,000 lumen 4xBridgelux arrays
15,000 lumen 1xBridgelux array
10,000 lumen 1xBridgelux array