Test/review of Vapcell ICR14500 1000mAh (Gold) 2018

:+1: I was about to say the same thing. You can’t just compare the volume between the 14500 and 18650 because there is a higher ratio of unusable space in a 14500 cell compared to 18650. Getting 1,000mah out of the actual volume that can be used for energy storage is pretty amazing already. Even the Sanyo/Panasonic cells can only get 840mah.

I wouldn't call that amazing, it's more like there's nothing better. There could be something much better.

Sanyo/Panasonic stopped developing 14500s years ago, probably a decade already. If they were to use their current technology in 14500s we would see 1500+mAh cells with higher discharge rates.

Structurally speaking a 14500 can does not need to be as hull thick as a 18650, so while the useable space argument is valid, it is also invalid to me.

Cheers ^:)

When you consider that it takes so much space in a li-ion cylinder battery for the anode and cathode and the casing, the available space for the electrolyte decrease as the sizes decreases.
If you had a 18500 battery (50mm length) and it takes 8mm for the anode, cathode, button top and CID and a little space left for the connections.
That’s 16% of the battery space length used just to make the battery and 84% left for the electrolyte.
Now if you make a 18250 battery (25mm Length) you still have to have that same 8mm just to make the battery, but how much is left for the electrolyte.
25mm - 8mm = 17mm left for electrolyte. That’s 32% of the battery space length used to just make the battery and 68% for the electrolyte.
18500 84% electrolyte
18250 68% electrolyte
Same thing happens when you start shrinking the diameter. Making a thinner case as Barkuti pointed out or figuring out a shallower way for the anode and cathode might improve more space for the electrolyte.

The Soshine 14500 900mAh is using the DLG NCM14500-850 cell core, while the Vapcell 14500 1000mAh is using the new generation DLG NCM14500-950 cell core, as shown by my tests below.

Vapcell also offers a button-top version of this cell (they added the top on their own), but the original DLG cell core is cheaper.

I just saw some 2800mAh 14500s advertised on Amazon!

Anyone believe that?

No reviews, yet.

Well, the highest rated (real) 18650 is 3500 mAh. Just scaling that down to 14500 size, with no other considerations taken, the most you could expect is just a bit under 2100 mAh. That’s still a lot more than we’ve ever seen in real life. But 2800 mAh should be impossible.

Fake, Scam what ever you wanna call it, the highest is the vapcell here in this thread at the moment.
Just because it’s on amazon doesn’t mean a thing, here’s another example that surely no one actually believes.
https://www.amazon.com/9800mah-Rechargeable-Flashlight-Electric-Flashlights/dp/B07RXKCZN2/ref=sr_1_6?keywords=18650&qid=1562107454&s=gateway&sr=8-6
All 8 together might make 9800mah, that only be 1225mah each. That seems more realistic.

Looks like they just changed the voltage from 1.2 to 3.7 on some NiMh wrappers and left the mAh the same.

I think they are actually lithium 3.6v non-rechargeable, not lithium ion rechargeable and mislabeled when translating from the original language to English.

Then the mAh are in line with other 3.6v lithium primaries.

Nice. Are you willing to briefly share how do you attain those graphs toobadorz? Tools and etc. Thanks.

Shame on you Soshine and Vapcell, yet again rating inflation.

Source: https://gfycat.com/simpledarlingbrant

18650 cylinder volume (cm³) is πr² × h = π(0.81) × 6.5 = ≈16.5405cm³

14500 cylinder volume (cm³) is πr² × h = π(0.49) × 5.0 = ≈7.6969cm³

This means 14500 is 100 × (7.6969/16.5405) = 46.5337% the volume of 18650.

3500 × ≈0.465337 = ≈1628.68

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

:-)

OOPS, I forgot to do the whole math. You’re right. So, it’s even worse than I said.

That’s a little higher than what actually can be achieved.
Consider that the anode and cathode take up a percentage of the cell, the smaller the cell the higher the percentage of volume the anode and cathode take up.
If we say in a 18650 the anode and cathode take up 6.5mm (makes the math easier) that’s 10 % of the total volume, 90% left for electrolyte.
For a 18350 cell the anode and cathode is the same 6.5mm and that’s 20% of the total volume, that just leaves 80% of the cell volume left for electrolyte.
If you made a cell 18065 with the same 6.5mm anode and cathode there would be no space left for electrolyte, yet the cell still has volume.

Can understand moderator007, I could also consider the cell can thickness and bla bla bla. To me, and you know, these are just excuses. Everything can be properly scaled up or down and counter volume losses.

I used to test the batteries I bought with EBD-A20H (an electronic load for up to 20A discharge) and a 30A version BF-2A (a 4-wire battery fixture).

I purchased 4 of these from Vapcell direct off aliexpress (in their 11.11 sale) and after receiving them last week one died on the first use!
They all came at ~3.62v and took an initial charge but then the first cycle in a light I got a low voltage warning abnormally soon and saw it was at 3v after just a day of lite usage so I took it out and it’s self discharged to 90mv in just 3 days time.
The other 3 seem to be maintaining their voltage and the 2 others I’ve tried so far seem to work fine.

Should I chalk it up to cheap China sourced cells or ask for a replacement? The other pair of them I’ve been running are from liionwholesale and they’re button tops (these aliexpress ones are flat top) so I was a little concerned from the get-go…

You should pm Vapcell_Dennis here. He is always very helpful. Always report problems to the manufacturers to help them fix problems and improve otherwise they would not be aware of it.

I need replacing battery 14500 for sonicare.
What to use
Vapcell ICR14500 1000mAh - 3A
or
Sanyo UR14500P 800mAh - 5A

What you sugest me?

svicar1, the Vapcell ICR14500 1000mAh (950mAh manufacturer rating) is overall better than the Sanyo UR14500P without a doubt. The UR14500P isn't a 5 A cell, but more like 3C or ≈2.4 A tops.

The choice is clear, imho.

And Shockli is even marginally better.

I don't think there really is any actual difference (besides cell grade or batch and etc.), both Shockli and Vapcell buy their 14500 “1000 mAh” cells from the same OEM as far as I understand (Heter cell; the manufacturer rating is 950 mAh, btw).