Lumintop FW1A discussion and review

A cheaper and better HDS

Yeeehaaaaaw!

Well, I don’t necessarily think that’s fair. Cheaper, of course, but better depends on your needs. This certainly won’t have a rotary interface, and as well as my Lumintop lights have been built I have no doubt that HDS can manage somewhat better quality and warranty support for the prices they charge - so I’m not sure about better.
I would be comfortable saying cheaper, brighter, and more modification-friendly, sure.

Yup, super excited for this one. Possibly more so than the FW3*. I think they need to add a bit of extra detail/knurling to the extended head though but that’s nit-picking.

Shorty tubes will most likely be compatible too.

Looks amazing! Will the bezel and reflector be available as standalone parts? Or just as a complete/built light?

:heart_eyes: :heart_eyes:

Aside from constantly annoying Neal, I have no inside information - but I would guess only as a complete light. To install it on the FW3A you’d have to drill new holes in the shelf for the leads, which is a bit silly to expect customers to do. Considering how few people will be willing to drill and solder their own lights together, I would be surprised to see a kit.

Been watching this on FB, going to be a must have! Would have liked to see a TIR to help keep the length down.

Thank you for the feedback. I assumed the same, just thought a question wouldn’t hurt due to the strong modding community on here. I also believe the absolute number of people who are willing to “share” a FWxA host in order to run two different lights would be small.
You don’t actually save that much time or money if you have to desolder the mcpcb in order to run a different head/reflector.

I don’t think the extra length will be an issue at all - the current FW3A is one of the shortest 18650 lights ever, and a bit of length may even help with the ergonomics for some people with bigger hands. I can only think of Fenix that’s using those strange ultra short TIR optics, are there others? Or more readily available options?

This and the 18350 tubes is good news.

The larger bezel + head without the led and driver portion would something to nag lumintop about.

I need someone to describe why they prefer a single emitter light over the three. I don’t understand, especially the one expressed desire that an optic was preferred? Just curious.

I just wrote this on reddit so I’ll paste it below:

Overtly floody beams are sort of a luxury. Indoors, or at very close distances, they take the guesswork and effort out of having to direct a light and choose where it’s pointed. Working under your sink? Perfect, the entire cabinet is daylight now. So what’s not to like?

If I’m carrying a single EDC light with me, I want it to be versatile, and I realized just how single-purpose floody beams were when we were walking the dog at night, and my wife saw a bird in the middle of the river and wanted to know what kind it was - so I put my Astrolux S43 on turbo, with well over 1000 lumens, and got a great look at… small particles in the air. The light wasn’t able to get about 25 feet away effectively, even with the battery-draining excess of full FET - something that a simple Convoy S2+ could have easily done on most of the lower modes.

Take that same S2+, or this Unicorn, and it will get to the middle of the river and beyond with ease. If I find myself in the cupboard looking for a leak, it can do that just fine too. On the off chance that I find it too throwy, I can diffuse it or ceiling bounce - but that’s almost never required.

Like I said earlier, there’s a point where this isn’t the case anymore. Something like a C8 really doesn’t cut it for walking around at night, because the hot spot is too intense, and it’s nearly impossibe to see what’s up ahead on the trail and watch my feet at the same time. But for me, even the Dobermann Pro with a 34 mm head and a domeless LED is perfectly fine for ‘general’ use. And there are times when I want an extremely floody light - mainly for hands-free applications, like a headlamp. But for a straight-bodied light, a 1” reflector or optic is pretty much the sweet spot for me.

I find that sometimes to much flood an be a bad thing. If you are trying to focus on one thing in one general direction a little bit of focused light works very well. Small reflector lights have a decent amount of spill and generally a decent size hotspot, triples and quads just tend to blast light forward with no real aim… other than forward. I mentioned TIR because it will give you some control, measured in degrees, where the majority of the light will go. With a reflector, you do not gain that control.

OK, I asked. I find a TIR with some flood like the FW3A is more suited for most of my wants than any reflector light. I use other lights when I want less flood. Just my type of use, the way I like. It’s a good thing there are lots of lights to choose from. :slight_smile:

I always have my FW3A in a pocket.

Almost perfect. Don’t want orange peel. I want to see a 300M rating in a 4”–100mm package. Fix mm

OP reflectors have been shown to have a pretty negligible impact on throw, while cleaning up any artifacts in the beam - so I’m more than happy with OP.

Check out the Fireflies E01.
It is a single emitter. Not a flood, not a thrower, but the single emitter with the (TIR?) optic has a nice narrow beam that throws very well. And handles heat a lot better than the FW3 design.
I ran a test last night and put the E01 into turbo for 90 seconds. Never stepped down, temp was 46 C.

Totally different light. A 34 mm head is a bit large for EDC, and it’s 20% longer than the FW1A. Really it’s pushing the boundaries of an EDC, and closer in size to the Dobermann Pro - not to mention that I don’t trust their build quality one bit.
Also, saying a FET light ‘never stepped down’ doesn’t really jive with me - of course it did. It stepped down just as fast as the cell voltage did which, on turbo, is not insignificant.
It’s pretty clear from Maukka’s review that the fireflies lights are in a different size class altogether.

That is an EO7 in the pic.
I do not pocket carry lights, these work will in a small belt holster.
The E01 is a bit bigger than the FW, but it also uses a 21700 5000 Mah battery, so you get longer run times.
Always lit switch
If you can’t see it step down, it didn’t step down.

And I don’t know how you can say “build quality” with a straight face.
I have 4 of the FW3, and not one of them worked out of the box (they all work now after reading like 2000 posts about how to get them to work).