I think your DNS server is resolving to wrong address because of the way he killed old site, made new one and then redirected. Try flushing your DNS cache.
I suggest you add the business name to the title of your home page. It will make finding the site again easier after saving the URL to favorites/bookmarks.
I suggest you to ask your web developer to change the Magento’s favicon with your own company/store icon as well as change the “Home page” text (as suggested by MyRants) for better recognition.
Hey Hank, new site looks great. I was trying to sign into the old one to check an order and it says suspended. Any idea when I’ll be able to check my order?