Ultimate LED Bulbs - Ultra High CRI - The Honorable Quest

Thanks for the test! I wanted to get a below-2700K LED bulb with negative duv, this one looks great.

Guys, if I want to create a "BLF Bulb Quality factor™" to "scientifically" order my first post table, what would you advise as metrics/formula? Which Rx, or other parameters to factor in?

Draft proposal => Qf = [(Ra *1)+(R9*3)+(R12*3)+(Rf*3)] / 10

There is a point at which perfection can only be measured and not be seen at all by eye, are you sure you did not pass that point already? :wink:

I guess you mean France is converting from B22 to E27, and the majority of Europe uses E27?

That's a valid point, but from a number POV we have better offers from alternate manufacturers regarding R9 and R12 than the ExpertColors. Now, could I, could you, could the readers here, feel the differences, and what color rendering would they prefer? That's a good question.

To be sure about that, we'd need a setup with every "bulb contestant", and be able to blindly switch between the lights, and slowly build a prefered order. Kind of an ABX test adapted to lights infact.

But, isn't the title of this thread "Ultra High CRI"? And well, the subtitle of this thread could also be "Never accept compromises, to the infiniiiite and beyond..."

Slip of the tongue, thanks to point it to me! I'm correcting that.

I was actually thinking about this a few weeks ago. I think you are including the right things. But the best results would best be a simple scale from 1 to 10, but not try to fit the scale to the whole market today. For example, a 5 would actually be an above average light today, a 10 would be a future perfect light, and a 1 and 2 would be many of the lights on the market today. The idea of fitting the scale like that would so it doesn’t become obsolete by not accounting for improved technology in the next few years.

yes the blue zone is very small, with blue peak is mild at 23% only.

Talking about the blue peak, Luminus has brought a new 3030 led on the market that has the cyan gap filled up (or even made into a cyan peak) so that high CCT’s can be made with a lower blue peak. It is called Luminus “Salud”.

Not high CRI but here’s the Ikea Trådfri 1000 lm E27 smart bulb:
Imgur

Professional lightning Philips CRI97 spotlights, I have them here in my living room

Philips Master GU10 LED Spot 5.5W 375Lm WW dimmable

They got also CRI90 E27 lamps here
2700K
https://www.lighting.philips.de/prof/led-lampen-und-roehren/led-gluehlampen/corepro-ledbulb-gluehlampenform/929002069502_EU/product
2200K
https://www.lighting.philips.de/prof/led-lampen-und-roehren/led-gluehlampen/master-ledbulb-gluehlampenform/929002218602_EU/product
2700K filament
https://www.lighting.philips.de/prof/led-lampen-und-roehren/led-gluehlampen/led-lampen-mit-klassischem-gluehfaden/929002019002_EU/product

CRI90 E14
https://www.lighting.philips.de/prof/led-lampen-und-roehren/led-kerzen-und-tropfenlampen/classic-led-kerzen-und-tropfenlampen-klar/929002018002_EU/product

Philips claim 90CRI
https://www.lighting.philips.com/main/prof/led-lamps-and-tubes/led-bulbs/master-ledbulbs

And
https://www.airam.fi/en/product/v7640-2256/4711539/led-op-a60-10-5w-940-e27-cri90-bx/294/1

Livarno Lux bulbs from Lidl are advertised as high CRi (>95, sometimes 97 or even 100), they’re pretty cheap at 1,5-5€ each (depends on the country and model) and they come in various shapes, sockets (G10, E14, E27), from 250 to 806 lumens. Sources:

Germany

Poland

Spain

Ikea >> sub-90CRI seems not enough for our "Ulta High CRI" topic. But it's great that a "big name of house equipments" is putting CRI on its product. A good way to eduquate consumer in the long run. Do they offer better lines?

Philips >> GU10 CRI97 offering is great, for sure. Why don't they also make E27 bulbs out of it is a mystery. Maybe a double targetting bias, where GU10 is used to target shops/pro displays, whereas E27 is viewed as consumer only format, and consumer as deemed not interested in great CRI?

Airam >> Do you have tests or more detailled specs somewhere about this bulb?

LIDL >> claimed specs are interesting, but I can't help but being dubious about a CRI100 offering (who would/could be their manufacturer?). That is making me "scientifically doubt" about pretty much their other claims too, as a consequence. Other bias in my reasonments is that with those "white branded" products, the inside of the product could change with each production run. Any tests (and more precise references) somewhere ?

The "trick" with pretty much manufacturer claiming good/great CRI will fall under the CIE vs TM-30 measurements caveats. The common old CRI index is proven to be unfit to adequately qualify LEDs flux (too much pastel colors, not taking into account full spectrum, etc). That's why TM-30 is aiming to perfect that situation and that's why I've added from the start R9 (deep red), R12 (deep blue) and Rf (full spectrum) values.

A manufacturer can claim a great CRI value (so based only on R1-R8 values), but producing for instance "badish" results on R9 and R12. And as such giving a "meehish" render in our homes.

I've started to rebuild my table, with the BLF Bulb Quality factor™ proposal, you cand find it there.

Have to think a bit more about the proposal of Joshk for its scale.

IKEA Ledare, type LED1708R5.
A dimmable GU10 bulb that uses very warm leds at the lowest brightness setting and gets cooler tint at higher setting by gradually mixing in a cooler set of leds and switching off the warm set at the highest setting.

Lowest settings, just the warm leds:
CCT=2060, duv=+0.0012, CRI=93.6, R9=58, R12=98, Rf=93.2, Rg=96.8

An intermediate setting, some cooler light mixed in:
CCT=2450, duv=+0.0005, CRI=93.8, R9=60, R12=92, Rf=92.6, Rg=99.4

Highest settings, just the cooler set of leds, warm leds are off:
CCT=2640, duv=+0.0008, CRI=91.7, R9=54, R12=88, Rf=90.3, Rg=100.0

IKEA Ledare, type LED1521R6
A 2700K 90+CRI GU10 bulb, non-dimmable

CCT=2850, duv=+0.0014, CRI=91.9, R9=59, R12=83, Rf=91.0, Rg=99.9

too bad all IKEA above BBL

The newest insights are that (“western”?) people prefer the tint well under the BBL, which these bulbs are not, but they are only slightly above it, and I do not see an ugly tint.

Really quick post. First, thanks for all your new test additions guys.

Then, here is the updated table, with a first run at ordering it:

Since there are so many measurements being posted, I just want to remind everyone you should allow LED bulbs to warm up for a while before testing because Duv tends to drop significantly.

I so want to try some of these