It’s not weird. Musical acts on tv are usually pop music stars. Movie music is not usually written or performed by those acts. It’s usually written by people who specialize in writing music for movies and tv. Or, the movies use popular music from the past that is selected for particular scenes you are watching as you listen to the music. Listening to current pop musicians on stage is a different experience than listening to movie music or specially-selected older music while watching a movie.
I do not watch TV at all, but I’m aware of “How they sing” crap shows. I feel the same way.
But… I do watch a lot of movies. Music in a movie is essential and must “fit”.
I didn’t ever rate movies by soundtrack, but well remembered are Pulp Fiction, The Rock, Natural Born Killers, Blue Velvet, Easy Rider, Back to the Future series, Trainspotting, Lord of the Rings and many more.
That music will last forever.
They’re different genres. Eg, I’ve got the “Dead Space” soundtrack, which is good listening, rather orchestral. Just got a Hans Zimmer concert which is pretty good, too.
John Tesh(!) has 2 good ceedees, “Pure Movies” and “Pure Movies 2” (1 is better).
The “24” soundtrack (seasons 1-3, another for seasons 4-5, again, the first being better) is downright awesome.
I’ve got quite a few “soundtrack” ceedees that are their own entities. Better if you’ve seen the movie (eg, “Jumper”).
The one for “Star Trek: Nemesis” is beyond words. Amazing…
“Regular” music is just that, a collection of songs released at the same time in one batch (ie, the album). It may be “self-contained”, even tell a story (“The Wall”, ferinstance), or be rather random.
A lot of my classic albums on vinyl, when rereleased on ceedee, often contain bonus tracks. All too often, those tracks just don’t seem to “fit” the original album.
In contrast, OSTs generally have that underlying “theme” connecting all the tracks.
Actually, about the “Nemesis” soundtrack, the physical/hardcopy/whatever ceedee version I got is my reference, as far as amazingness. Versions I’ve seen online <coff>, with lots more tracks, seems out of order, random, and completely disjointed. So be choosy over which version you’d get.
Usually, the music makes all the difference in a movie. Music plays a significant role in the film because it gives the tone and the plot’s mood. It plays into your emotions and feeling. Let’s take the Titanic film. You felt every emotion of the actors because of the melody. Now, all people associate the song “My heart will go on” with sacrifice and a romantic mood. All girls start crying when listening to this song. The same happens in the commercial video or when creating a travel video. Before the pandemic, I used to travel a lot. I have a Youtube channel where I post my escapes. People like my videos because I create the right atmosphere with the royalty free sound effects music.
Did BLF member teacher (from Alabama, USA) actually get banned for being a troll? Maybe you are talking about another „teacher“ but I had come to know him as a courteous and decent guy but out of a sudden he just left the forum. Of course, there might be two sides of the story and I am just not well informed…