The There Are No Stupid Questions Thread

The ML cells can be recharged - if you try to recharge the CRs they’re likely to explode. And that’s the real meaning of primary vs secondary cells: primaries are disposable and secondaries are rechargeable.

There is also likely to be a voltage difference, which could harm things.

I exchanged a couple of emails with Aloft Hobbies about the QB 26800 cells. They don’t know who the manufacturer is, either, and their supplier isn’t talking. lol. So…may remain an eternal mystery. They are due to receive another shipment of 26800 cells in the next week or so, so that’s good news. May be worth comparing their landed/shipped cost with your source now. I’d email them to ask about shipping, though, because apparently their website software tends to go exorbitant for int’l shipments but they can do it cheaper.

How bad are we talking on that shipping? A single cell on Aliexpress costs $7-10 to ship.

Cheap for me so far. Last order was in October for two 21700 and it was $5.25. First time with 4x26800 and one 21700 it was $10.85. When I order from Illumn, Liion, or IMR it seems like it’s never less than $8-10 if any cell is involved, no matter the weight…they do accessories-only for a bit cheaper.

That said, the post office has increased prices a bit and I see that Aloft’s prices on cells have gone up recently as well…could be that shipping has followed suit, just have to plug in an order and see I guess. If it seems too high I wouldn’t hesitate to email them. Their shipping was ridiculously fast for the postal service, too, each time.

One emitters suddenly burn out of my SP36. Are the other 3 LED taking more amps?

What could be the possible reasons for a Reylight Pineapple brass not to turn on? I tried with a Li ion and a NI-MH battery. The contact should be good because the threads are brass.

Retaining rings? Make sure everything’s snug.

Hello! Not sure if this been asked or not. I’ve been seeing a lot more lately the designation R9080 or R9050 when referring to an LED. I understand high CRI but I’m guessing it’s something more specific than that. Can someone please explain to me what those numbers mean exactly?

Nichia’s designation. The first set refers to Ra (R average of R1 to R8 – broad spectrum), the second set to R9 (the redshift).

So both are CRI90 but one have more red reproduction? Is that it?

The 2nd one, R9050, has less red representation. Without the rest of the analytics, I would infer a greener tint. But the overall balance is in the 90% colour rendering. It could have also more yellow or another artifact. Generally, Nichia’s are known for their good emitters. It’s white wall hunting and side by side comparisons that demark the small differences. With time, your eye can see these individually.

Yes, both 90 CRI

@story, the answer is yes, as the battery packs will still be pushing about the same amount of power, which means current pushed to each LEd will go up a bit.

Ah ok! I get it now. Thanks!!

Thanks.

I have TrustFire TR-3T6, can I reflow 3 SFT-40 to replace the CREE XM-L2?

Would add that although 9050 and 9080 are both rated 90CRI, the 9080 is closer to 95+ CRI in practice. Some higher CCT 519A's (rated 9080) measure above 97; even seen one measure 100.0 on an Opple meter.

That should be possible. The XM-L2 is a current sensitive led just like the SFT40 so most likely the current of the flashlight will be somehow limited. You should use copper DTP MCPCBs, though.

Can anyone give me some basic information about the driver this light uses?
https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005001973586200.html?spm=a2g0o.order_list.0.0.21ef1802cLfTQV
Convoy C8+ with KW CSLNM1.TG and 12 group driver.
(I own this light)

Is this whats called a biscotti driver?
What is guppydrv?

Need someone to point me in the right direction here.
Thanks

https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002639038647.html?spm=a2g0o.store_pc_groupList.8148356.47.6f605518E5de3v

Is this a “boost” driver?

His 12-group driver is not Biscotti but it’s highly derived from it. Back in the day, ToyKeeper made the Bistro firmware, and then later trimmed it down a little to make Biscotti just for Simon. I don’t know if he’s still using Biscotti on anything but maybe…2-3 years ago he had some issues and then developed his new 12-group, very similar to Biscotti in features.

Dr. Jones, TomE, and ToyKeeper (and others) designed several of the popular firmware programs years ago, many of which are still used today. Probably a lot to wade through, but a forum search for each will tell you as much as you want to know. Richard at Mountain Electronics still offers lots of them and has good quick rundowns of each. Take a look at his drivers and scroll down to where he describes the firmwares offered…several have a separate page that you can click the links to read more about (features and operation, sometimes more). Here’s one that has most of them listed: 26mm FET+7135 Driver - MTN-26DDm - 1S Input Voltage

As for the driver in your light, he says down the page that is has a max of 4.8 amps (4800mA), and he also says the light gives about 1100 lumens with that emitter. Measurements tell the truth but Simon is usually pretty accurate and he lists out-the-front actual lumens rather than paper lumens (those being a theoretical max based on component specs, not accounting for efficiency or losses from resistance, reflectors/optics, lenses, etc).

If you were to browse the data sheet for that emitter, you might expect the driver to only be delivering around 3.5 amps for the stated lumens and with the bin he has chosen to use, but again, all that extra mumbo jumbo reduces actual light output from theoretical. I assume the bare emitter he’s selling separately is the same as what he’s using in the lights (that’s usually the case), and if so then he’s picked one from the available bins that has a bit lower lumen output, but it also has a lower required voltage and a better spot in the tint chart which reduces the green a bit. This is what he usually does, picking one with a good balance of performance and light color, rather than playing the numbers game for max-advertising-lumens.

If you want to browse the data sheet for that emitter, here’s a link. Even if it’s all greek to you, it’s fun to take a look and I know when I first started doing so it actually helped me understand a couple things, and then I started to explore all the other things I had no clue about, and understood more after that. If it produces more unstupid questions, post ’em up. lol

And Simon’s link to the emitter, where in the title description you can see the binning information (model)….which is 6N for “brightness group”, 15 for voltage group, and ebxD46 for chromacity/tint group (pages 4 and 5 on the data sheet): https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4001238336707.html

@Correllux
Thank you very much!
This is a lot of good information for me to work with.
All very helpful to me right now.

Is it a boost driver though?
Im wondering what makes it different than the “regular” convoy drivers.
Its “designed specifically for the 12v GTFC40 LED.”

So is it “boosting” the Cells power to meet the LEDs requirements?

Im mostly just wondering if its a “better” driver?
Boost is supposed to be more efficient right?

Its not critical informaion I need. Just curious and trying to learn.