The There Are No Stupid Questions Thread

I’m probably going to get a lot of different answers from the dealer and from you guys. I guess I got to figure out which one’s best! So I bought some unprotected GA button tops Black Friday sale. Probably won’t need them for 2 years cuz my MJ1 are doing well. The question is, can I store these two years continuous, or after 1 year should I take them out of storage charge them up and then back into storage?

Thx

^
I make a point of testing my long-term stored batteries for charge level every 6 months or so. If they start dropping down below 3.8v, I charge them back up. I don’t have very many. Most of them are laptop pulls, which are lower amperage than the high amperage (over 5A) batteries that I use for high power consumption flashlights.

In general, if you’re not using many batteries for over a year… you’re stockpiling too much. One good exception is non-rechargeable cells that you want to keep on hand for emergencies or quick stand-ins for rechargeables like AA and CR123A. The CR123A is a remarkable cell that can often keep for 10 years on a shelf before starting to degrade.

^

What level do you store them at? You mentioned dropping below 3.8 volts? I store mine on 3.55 or 3.6 volts.

I bought these because they were on sale. As I said I don’t need them probably for a year and a half or two years whenever my other batteries go bad.

Question is if that’s the case, is it okay to keep them stored for two consecutive years checking voltages but not charging them up again unless necessary.

The higher the state of charge the higher the calendar ageing, but specifically there is a threshold around 50~60% where above it degrades faster. So no, stored li-ion cells shouldn’t be topped off, in the first place they are charged from the factory at 30%, due to shipping restrictions but also because it’s a good place to be since it’s under that threshold while leaving quite a bit of capacity for self discharge, which is quite low with li-ion, if the cell goes into negative SOC then it’s bad.
So just leave them as they are, they should be around 3.3~3.5V, you can check in one year and if you see them going towards 3.1~3V then you can get them back up to 3.5~3.6V.

First thing I do is a capacity test which I’m doing right now. After that I store them around 3.6 volts. My question was can they be stored for two continuous years or should after a year I take them and charge them and then put them back in the storage?

If they’re going from 3.5 volts or 3.6 volts down the 3 or 3.1 in a year, something is definitely wrong with those batteries. I’ve stored them for a year and they are the exact same or 100th of a volt lower many times.

The reason I asked the question is cuz somewhere where I Googled it said you shouldn’t store them for more than a year. If you do, charge them and then you can store them again. I never really heard of that method so that’s why I inquired about it.

I’m going to keep it simple!

I’m going to leave them stored for a year check them periodically and if I don’t need to use them after a year and the voltages are fine just let them be until I do need to use them.

That’s the same suggestion my hometown dealer gave me the one who sold me the batteries. He’s an engineer and knows pretty much about these batteries.

16340 batteries (rechargeable version of CR123A)
What’s the “practical” maximum mAh available? I still have a few from olden days, when 650mAh was common. I think the highest I’ve seen is 850mAh (Vapcell). I’m suspecting this would be about the limit—after all, there are 18350 cells as low as 900mAh, with highest around 1500mAh.
_

I imagine like thefreeman said that 3.5~3.6v is probably the ideal, in terms of minimal charge decay. I’ve found 3.8v to be fine and the cells sit at that level for a very long time. Trouble with testing this is that it’s so long to find out! If you have freedom of time, do a test. Have some cells at 3.5v and a couple at 3.8v. Note the charge on the battery (little label), with date. Then do a voltage test at 4, 6, 9, and 12 months. See what happens.

FWIW, you know those old notebook hole reinforcers? They look like flat mini peppermint lifesavers? Those are great to adhere to the positive end of 18650 cells. I write the post-charge resting voltage there, so I know which cells are the best and those that are lesser (for unimportant tasks).

How should I go about getting rid of about 20 LiIon cells?
Just drop them off at Home Depot?
They are all still nearly new, not dead.

Post in the WTS forum for Canada… maybe there might be someone nearby on BLF who’d be happy to take them off your hands?

Hjeh, I was just gonna jump in with “No prob, I’ll take ’em”. :clown_face::clown_face::clown_face:

@sunsethiker, they have higher rates of self-discharge.

Lots worse, relatively speaking.

If you leave lithium ion cells in a charger, and the charger is not plugged in, do the cells discharge more quickly than if they were not in the charger?

Usually yes, how much depends on the charger, this is something that HKJ always tests so check this on your charger review from him.

For example my charger: Review of Charger Zanflare C4

Which is pretty significant

Thank you, thefreeman!

I recently ordered a heat gun. Should I get a hot plate in addition? What do you do with a hot plate?

I bought a temperature & air flow controlled heat gun during the recent sale. It is called “T12 Heat Guns OLED Digital Display Temperature Soldering Station”. I thought having a heat gun can be useful. I can think of several interesting uses for my heat gun. Heating flashlights to loosen glued threads, heat glues and stickers for easy removal, and possibly remove and reflow LEDs.

However, I heard that reflowing LEDs on MCPCB using heat guns may not be easy because MCPCB can soak up a lot of heat and LEDs can be damaged by heat. Temperature controlled hot plate seems to be an adequate tool for working on LEDs. However, I don’t think I will replace LEDs often. Many of lights I own have RGB aux leds and they are not mod friendly because of the small wires and tight spaces.

If I am not going to reflow many LEDs, what are other uses for a hot plate? Only other uses that I might have is heating cold coffee on the hot plate. The model of hot plate I have in mind is MECHANIC ET-10 hot plate. Price is not bad at 30 USD.

Good question! Wondered about that myself but never thought to ask.

Yes, the mcpcb will soak up heat, as it should. Once it’s saturated then the heat output of the gun will start to be more controllable. It’s as easy as other methods as long as you have a good way to hold the board so that both hands are free (gun and tweezers/flux). It depends on the emitter, but generally yes, you want to use as low a temperature as possible to let things flow and get the job done without undue delay. Most of our white emitters are pretty tough but sometimes the domes will become soft or damaged with extended heat, so be careful not to bump them hard with tools. UV emitters are much more sensitive to heat. Most manufacturers state that their emitters should only be reflowed twice but we frequently do that another time or two and things seem well. The heat guns that are able to provide adjustable heat and adjustable flow are the best…often low air flow but still having moderate to high heat is a great combination (so you don’t blow tiny components off the board…). There’s no need to get overly precise about it but the graphic below that I borrowed from the internet is kind of a typical reflow heat profile (geared more toward hot oven work than hot plates or heat guns, but same difference for the most part). You can see that there is both a peak maximum temperature that should be avoided really, but a companion time frame at which the emitter should be able to tolerate that heat without damage…and the profile ramps up slowly (heat saturation and to avoid thermal shock) before leveling out when the solder melting temperature is reached and you can do the job…then remove the heat as soon as possible and let it cool. Usually the temperatures are just about the same for all emitters but you can always check the data sheets for an emitters specs/numbers. And again, for a heat gun and hobby work, this reflow profile is just a good guideline that we can try to emulate without precise controls. Heck, people successfully use cigarette lighters and propane torches to do this job…ok when done smartly. :slight_smile:

Tiny tiny components are challenging by hand. The heat gun and different nozzles are what pros use for handwork with this stuff…just some flux and tweezers (and magnification if you need it) and a whole world opens up compared to trying to use an iron. But with the right techniques and iron tips (and flux flux flux) there’s still a lot that can be done without a heat gun if you have the skills. Heat guns are also fantastic for bending many plastics, gently preheating a surface for paint or glue, and drying small parts with nooks and crannies after a bath.

The hot plate could be used for other electronics work, especially with single-sided boards. Some adhesive mixing or curing, some catalyst coatings like a little heat for mixing (really niche stuff). If you were doing some solder or bending work on larger-but-small metal things then putting the item on the plate for heat saturation makes some jobs easier or for prolonged work that might be a pain in the butt with a torch or iron. And of course making your own chemistry lab experiments…ha. I’ve come to prefer a little hotplate for doing my emitters. I got the tiny Miniware version and love it…but man it’s tiny. That Mechanic’s version looks great and it’s very affordable (and probably better than many of the larger cheap versions out there for labs and such).

Thank you very much for the quality info. Looks like I would not have much use for a hot plate. I came by some youtube videos on the Miniware hotplate. I liked the idea, but they were pricy for my budget for hot plate. By the way, I recently received Miniware TS101 soldering iron. I really like compactness of their tools. It is very small so it can be easily put away inside a drawer.

I have a magic arm and a clamp (photo equipment), so holding the heat gun should not be an hard. However, I remember reading a post that heat guns should be applied from the bottom not from the top. That seems to be quite awkward to work on.

Would it be okay to put the MCPCB on silicone soldering mat and blow hot air from above? I think it would be okay if the air temperature is controlled…

What is a DC Fix ? Also, what does DC stand for?