26650 battery help needed for 15x

Does anyone have suggestions for a protected 26650’s for a 15x that has been souped up. It works great with king kong unprotected but I need something protected that has higher drain than a trustfire protected because it’s popping the protection on them. This is a light that takes 4 batteries and I suspect it’s direct drive on high. It’s wired with three of the emitters to the positive wire in series and then four more emitters to each of them. So four batteries per five emitters. I wired it with 20 gauge wire. I sold it, but the guy needs advice on which batteries to buy and he doesn’t want to run unprotected batteries in it.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

KK 4000 protected from CNQ might be a good option. Never seen a test on them. But expect performance like KK, but generally 0,1V lower voltage due to protection circuit. Battery length might be an issue?

There is also the Soshine 26650, but they are probably not as happy with high current+ as the KK. Id guess they are out due to that. They were testet here. They are very long too! In that same thread some IMR cells were mentioned. Those might be an even better option than the protected KK for your light (but then there is obviously lower capacity).

Thanks I’ll check that out.

I'm not a battery guy, but it sounds like you need IMR's. They don't come with protection, but are supposed to be safer as long as one follows the normal safety conventions. Less capacity is probably why you sound like you are avoiding them though.

I think he just wants as many options as possible. I agree that IMR’s are probably the best bet. Although I think the protected king kongs would work to. But I don’t know if I would take the chance when the IMR’s will work for sure and they have a lot of capacity when there is four of them.

Any suggestions on where to buy the IMR’s?

Those KKs say 2-5A discharge? Can’t be right for KKs can it?

Also, INR, not IMR is the safer high discharge afaik. True?

I don’t know for sure but according to the batterywiki site IMR is Safer than INR but INR is still supposed to be safe chemistry and won’t runaway and discharge from use but can if punctured, incinerated etc.

i use kk 4000 inr’s because i was told they are safer.

but i would tell the guy to just purchase these MNKE’s instead, they are hard to come by and they sell out quick
http://edcplus.com/mnke-imr26650-3700mah-p-5.html
i bought my mnke’s here and they are the real deal.

Thanks.

enerpower cells would do it but with the shipping they’d cost almost as much as the light.

http://item.mobileweb.ebay.com/viewitem?sbk=1&nav=SEARCH&itemId=261156005924

Wow they must use gold instead of Cobalt or Nickel. Are they IGR’s :wink:

They do look they they would do the trick though.

Wow, is it my imagination, or have Enerpower cells gone up in price? I was looking at them a while back and we had almost a possible group buy but they couldnt lower the price much. Another problem with them Werner brought up back then was the 8A discharge rate, they could not go higher as I remember, and with 15x 2A thats OK, but 15x 2.2A+ and it’ll pop protection…

is the light 15 emitters in parallel though? it reads to me that the emitters are wired series/parallel, I think they have gone up in price, I’d have to check on uk ebay because I know they were £33/pair plus shipping.

I also seem to remember the cells would do more than 8a but that’s where the protection tripped, its still, as far as I’m aware the highest limited protection circuit, what I’m saying is, if they wont do it, you might have to rule out protection circuits.

I also dont think I could get them shipped here then ship them across to you for less unfortunately.

I do know I want some, but almost a hundred quid for six is a bit much for me lol

just checked, their £36/pair on uk ebay or best offer with free shipping, I might have to put a bid in once I’ve sorted my PayPal out, its not verified yet and I’ve hit this years limit lol

Yeah thats exactly what stopped me last time…very steep.

I think it was said above its actually 3 sets of 5 wiring. HJK’s test showed 6.5A in the 3400 panasonic cells that were tripped, so we know its at least drawing over 26A. I’m questioning the wiring setup though, if its say just 27A that it will draw, thats 9A to each set of 5?

i think I’m being thick……

three groups of five parallel wired emitters in series.

does that not mean we “just” need the cells and driver to supply 15a to the circuit? assuming we’re aiming for 3a/emitter? or am I not understanding?

There are no real good possibilities, i know you dont want to hear it but it is like it is. These lights never have undervoltage protection. here is the devils circle: You need high maximum current because otherwise you would carry unused mass=> buy good batteries for high current=>they are empty fast=>need undervoltage protection=>there are no good batteries with good protection=>leads to lower current=>carry 2 kilos for a 3000lumen light I am away from 26650 in series lights because of this fact, the new multiemmiter light from kaidomain looks promising with 3p2s configuration. back to topic The enerdan groubuy price was 22Euro, so i would say the ebay link is similiar...maybe a bit more expensive with shipping and so on.... It looks like the circuit can handle more current but they don`t guarantee it. You have the 4s light so with 8A you get 110W, I would call this acceptable. I guess in reallife you get less current as the drivers are dissapointing. So go for the enerdan cells... I have not understand how the leds are wired.

|-LED--LED--LED-|
|-LED--LED--LED-|
|-LED--LED--LED-|
|-LED--LED--LED-|
|-LED--LED--LED-|

There are three emitters that are wired in series. So it goes + + + and then off of the three negatives four more emitters are wired in series. So what is that 3S5P? I got a large jump in lumens when I wired it with 20 gauge wire and put the copper on the spring. I am guessing that it’s direct drive but I don’t know if it’s true or not because it does work with two batteries it’s just not bright that way. I never tried it with protected batteries. I just didn’t think of it. It didn’t seem to be making any of the batteries that I used overheat and I have had that happen before when I was really pushing the amps through them.

Let’s say for the sake of argument that it’s 3S5P direct drive with 4 cells. How many amps would that be? I have NO idea how to figure something like that out.

No you aren’t, that’s exactly what I’m saying: how could it pop protection in 4x26650s with 5A discharge and 4x18650s with 6.5A discharge in that configuration…I’m thinking it has to be parallel…

That would give you a lot of amps, super duper lot of amps…

Has it pwm in high?

I have the 9xT6 which is direct drive with 3 batteries and 3s3p LEDS , but on high it has still PWM. This beast pulls 9-10A, the battery voltage goes down a lot so it sinks a lot fast.

If the LEDs are 3s5p, than every group gets 1/5 of the current through the batteries, so 10A*1/5=2A.
And every LED gets 1and1/3 of the voltage, so it is like a single XML on direct drive with 1.33 batteries…so it will see a lot current.