Review: NITECORE P25 SMILODON (XM-L U2 | 1 x 18650 / 2xR/CR123)

Nitecore's P25, has been bestowed the moniker "Smilodon". For those of you not up to date on long-extinct felidaes, Smilodons were a breed of saber-tooth-cat (not tiger as they are classified in the Machairodontinae subfamily vs. Pantherinae)

It was one of the largest "cats"; to wit, the smilodon populator had a body mass range of 220 to 360kg (290 to 790lb) and was likely one of the top predators of its time. I'm sure this was not lost on Nitecore's marketing team as the P25 has been touted for tactical applications. So, does it live up to the lineage of fearsome hunters or is it more a furry kitty? Let's see...


MFG SPECS
· Premium CREE XM-L U2 LED
· Maximum output of 860 lumens
· Integrated “Precision Digital Optics Technology” provides extreme reflector performance
· Boasts a peak beam intensity of 20,000cd and a throw distance of up to 283 meters
· High efficiency circuit board provides up to 325 hours runtime
· Integrated dual Picatinny connectors / rails provide a huge variety of mounting options
· Innovative single button two-stage switch offers a user-friendly interface (patented)
· Intelligent charging circuit with voltage detection charges safely and rapidly
· Integrated micro USB charging port is water, dust and impact resistant
· Eight rapidly switchable brightness levels to select from
· Integrated power indicator light displays remaining battery power (patented)
· Power indicator’s secondary function displays battery voltage (accurate to 0.1V)
· Intelligent charging circuit with voltage detection charges rapidly and safely
· Intelligent memory function stores preferred brightness setting
· Integrated spring-loaded impact absorption mechanism featuring reverse polarity protection (patented)
· Stainless steel titanium-plated two-way clip
· Stainless steel retaining ring protects the core components from damage
· Toughened ultra-clear mineral glass with anti-reflective coating
· Constructed from aero grade aluminum alloy
· Sturdy HAIII military grade hard-anodized
· Waterproof in accordance with IPX-8 (two meters submersible)
· Impact resistant to 1.5 meters
· Tail stand capability


PACKAGING / CONTENTS
I received an early production sample so was not provided w/any of the original packaging/accessories, however as posted on mfg's site, the P25 will ship with the following accessories: Quality holster, clip, tactical ring, lanyard, USB cable, spare tail cap and spare O-ring


CONDENSED VIDEO SUMMARY
Here is a high-level video summary of the P25 while while I work on fleshing out this review:
http://www.youtube.com/embed/Niu67L8PvWI


DESIGN & FEATURES
The P25 features a brushed stainless steel bezel that matches the gray finish nicely:


The smooth reflector was specially designed to eliminate rings:
[pic]
Case in point, the above shots shows beam cast by P25 on left and a different light also featuring XM-L U2 with similar output and smooth reflector.

The machined grooves towards the base of the head are not merely for aesthetics as they also help w/anti-roll:
[pic]

Likewise, the mass of the picitanny rails serve as heatsinks:
[pic]

The throat of the light features a 2-stage electronic switch (please see UI section for full details) that is surrounded by a clear rubber backlit by a blue LED:
[pic]
This LED conveys multi statuses depending on the frequency and duration of blinks (please see UI section for further details).

More to come...


SIZE / HANDLING

L to R: RediLast 3400 | XENO S3A | Shadow GF1 | Lighten6 Elite S1A | Shadow TC350 | ThruNite TN11 | Niwalker 550N3 |ThruNite TN11S | Crelant V9-T6 | NITECORE P25| Niwalker 600N1

The above is a shot of the P25 compared with other 1x18650 (mostly) turbo-head lights.

BEAMSHOTS
Indoors (5m)

L5




L4


L3


L2


L1


RUNTIME & OUTPUT
The relevant battery stats are provided above each runtime graph along with:
- Voltage of the battery at the start and end of the test
- Current draw
- Actual runtime using ANSI FL1 (first in HR and then in M so for the RL3400 on Turbo, read this as 2.6hrs or 153min)
- As of May 2012: Lumens measured on my PVC LMD @ 30 seconds
- Also for Turbo, captured the temperature: ambient, the head/fins at start and the max it reached (fan was used for all bats)


Max output measured @ 30 seconds was 1040lms w/a RediLast 3400 (note: although I calibrate my PVC LMD before each runtime/lumens testing, the ambient temp will also cause deviations in readings).

There is a general mild decline in output from the moment the P25 is first turned on which is gradually done between 3 - 7.5 mins until it regulates at 800lms for ~13min before a second step down to ~550lms where it'll stay regulated until the cell is no longer able to maintain output. So in total, it spends ~20min above or at 800lms. Overall heat wasn't bad, however, this is in consideration of the initial declining output which doesn't allow it to get all that hot.

Here in order for each cell are measurements for:
* step-down; timea
* avg lms in first minute + current draw and calculated runtime for each of the four non-turbo levels
* stand-by; since the P25 utilizes an electronic switch, the current draw + calculated time before cell is drained



CHARGING ALGO

The P25's built-in charger exhibits a CC/CV’ish curve that although not a perfect one is still pretty good:

- current starts to decline a few minutes after the start of charge, although not a steep drop, this does prolong charging a little
- termination current is ~70mA which is very good o Upon termination, there is a minute current draw of 3.62mA (due to the charging indicator light), otherwise stand by current drain is extremely little at 607µA w/spike to 1.4mA due to locater beacon
- charging end voltage hit 4.22v on some newer/low internal-resistance cells
- charging will reinitiate with very low current if power is interrupted and restored
- doesn’t seem to adapt to charging algo of external source, will always utilize its own charging algo and set
- charging rate maxed @ ~500mA; no advantage to using 2A input (e.g. Apple iPad 10W charger)
- is able to reset a tripped PCB on cell

Here is a deep dive of the charging and voltage read-out feature:
http://www.youtube.com/embed/94xER4o4vKs


MORE TO COME...


P25 GALLERY


=======
P25 provided by Nitecore for review.

Cheers turboBB.

Fantastic review of what looks like an awesome light. Thank you

I especially like your video reviews, I’ve watched most of them now. :smiley:

Thanks for the review, I'm looking forward to updates.

I've been researching 18650 flashlights and I'm pretty sure my next light will be the P25. I like the flexibility of being able to charge it through a USB port. I also like that it has an output of 860 lumens (looking forward to a P25 with the XM-L2). I, personally, like the User Interface too. I have the EA4 and really like the ease with which I'm able to access the different modes.

Another great review of an exciting looking light made all the better by the fact I’m awaiting it’s delivery. :bigsmile: For those that aren’t aware, fasttech are selling it at around $62 with BLF coupon code:

http://www.fasttech.com/search?P25

Considering it’s going for around $100 at other places, makes ordering this one from fasttech a no brainer.

Looks nice. Looks expensive but isn’t. $62 is not bad at all!

I really need to get this light,xml2 would have been great but I think it's fine the way it is.Excellent review and gallery shots turbo bb,just makes this light more tempting.

Indoor 5m shots added.

Hmm, just realised the holster for my P25 is too small, apparently this is a known issue for the first batch of P25’s and nitecore is directing customers do go to their sellers to get a replacement sent out.

Thread here from candlepower forums, I’ve just sent fasttech a message:

All P25 from first batch have wrong holsters. Nitecore have sent right holsters to their distributors. When I contacted FT, they answerd, that they will include free correct holster with my next order. And they did!! Smile

Thanks very much for the review! Frontpage’d and Sticky’d.

Thanks for the confirmation, I’ve had excellent service so far from fasttech so I’m sure I’ll get a response shortly.

What a sweet light! Thanks for the great review. 8)

How well does it throw compared to the other lights in the picture?

I didn't realize quite how large it is...

Thank you for the great review.

I just recieved my P25, love the light. nice interface features, the USB charger, and already have uses for the picanntiny mounts. :slight_smile:

Thanks guys! I've settled my video camera issues so hope to put up a comparo vid in the future.

Cheers,
Tim

Doesn’t the nitecore ec25 cobra have have about the same specs?

Model EC25 P25
Cost $57.00 @ FastTech $65.89 @ FastTech
Size

Smaller Head Diameter

Shorter

Larger Head Diameter

Longer

Weight 122g 171g
Brightness 860lm max. 860lm max
Lux 12,5Kcd 20Kcd
Switch Dual-Stage Electronic Side-Clicky Illuminated Electronic Dual-Stage Side Clicky Illuminated
AND Tail-Cap Forward Clicky
Tailstands Yes Yes
IPX-8 Yes Yes
Anodising HA-III HA-III
Lens Double-sided AR-coated mineral glass Double-sided AR-coated mineral glass
Min. Brightness 60lm 2lm
Max. Runtime 25hrs 325hrs
Charger (int.) No. Micro-USB slot.
Rails No. Two Picatinny, opposing sides.
Other Power Indicator

Shock-absorbing double battery springs.
Also comes in grey.
Power Indicator

The extra features are definitely worth the $ 7 - 8 dollar extra cost fo rthe P25.

The EC25 on turbo steps down after 3 minutes, the P25 after 20 minutes