Test/review of Charger SkyRC NC2600

Charger SkyRC NC2600











SkyRC mainly makes equipment for RC, that is chargers, power supplies, controllers and measurement equipment. This charger is a four channel analyzing charger and a update of the NC2500, i.e. it can both charge and discharge batteries. It has a Bluetooth link and a app can be downloaded to monitored and control the charger from a phone (Android or iPhone).

















The charger comes in a cardboard box with pictures of the app and specifications. The box has foam inside, making the charger very well protected for shipping.







The box contains the charger, a power supply and a manual (The manual can also be downloaded as PDF file).







The charger has a DC connector for power input.







And a usb connector for power output. This usb connector is powered while the charger is powered and can be used for charging other equipment.

It cannot supply power from the batteries.

I expect this to be much more useful in this size charger, than a battery power usb output.

The led is blue and is used to signal Bluetooth connection.







The buttons 1 to 4 is used to select display for each channel.

The up and down buttons is used to select function and current and the ENTER is used to accept selected value.



When a battery is put into a slot, the function must be selected for that slot. This must be done for each slot when filling them. If nothing is done the charger will start charging with the last selected current after some seconds.



The following functions can be selected:

  • CHARGE: Normal charge with selected current (200-2600mA)

  • DISCHARGE: Discharge battery with selected current (100-1000mA)

  • CYCLE: Charge and discharge a couple of times, both charge current, discharge current and cycle count (1-12) can be adjusted.

  • BREAK-IN: Slow charge the battery for 16 hours (100mA), discharges and then charges again.

  • REFRESH: Charge, discharge and charge, both charge current and discharge current can be adjusted.




The full display with everything on, notice the DONE indicator.



The display is optimized to view from above, and has a fairly limited viewing angle. I.e. sitting on a chair it is difficult to read the display of the charger when it is placed flat on the table. Using the tilting stand helps.
It is possible to change between mAh, mA, time, voltage using the number keys.



The charger has a fan hidden under it, to get as much air as possible into it there is a tilting stand.
The fan starts when required and can be heard for some distance (Couple of meters).
The fan will get air, even when the tilting stand is not used, due to the rubber feets (My IR photos was without tilting the charger).



The battery minus connections is in two steps, one for AA and one for AAA, the charger knows what size battery is in it. The metal at the side is the temperature sensor.



Here the AA and AAA batteries can be seen in the charger.








Phone interface using Android


I did have some trouble using the application. I used a HTC 10 phone.
Click the images for larger versions.



This is the overview picture where settings and values can be seen. Slot \#2 has a AAA cell in it, but the graphic is missing and as can be seen the data is not aligned with the batteries or number buttons.



Pressing the Detail button will show data for one battery, including a curve. I could not select the other batteries.



Pressing one of the number buttons makes it possible to select charger function for that slot or for all slots. This worked fine.



Pressing the gear at the top gives access to charger parameters and to adjust them. I did never get this to work.




Measurements
  • When not powered it will discharge a full battery with about 0.5mA

  • Voltage is measured with current off and is within about 0.02V

  • Charger remembers current settings and will use them as default next time.

  • Charger will restart charging after power loss, or battery insertion.

  • Power consumption when idle is 1.4 watt




NiMH charge

Charge rate between 200mA and 2600mA must be selected.



This curve looks like the charger uses -dv/dt to terminate, then a top-off charge and finally a trickle charge.
Display shows 1861mAh





Slot \#2 and \#3 looks the same, but \#4 looks like the charger terminated due to voltage.
Display shows 1868mAh, 1936mAh, 1760mAh



Using 0.2A charge current on AA cells is not a good idea, the current is too low for a normal -dv/dt termination and these cells do not get high enough voltage when charged with a low current. This could be adjusted with the phone application, if it had worked.



At 0.5A there is also a problem with termination, a lower -dv/dt value would probably fix that.



With 2A there is no problem terminating, this time on voltage.





All 3 high capacity cells terminates on -dv/dt and gets a top-off charge.
Display shows 2362mAh, 2387mAh, 2520mAh



Same with the AAA cell.
Display shows 791mAh



The charger is fast at detecting a full cell, but it do get the top-off charge.



The charger can charge four eneloops in 45 minutes.



When doing that it draws up to 2.8A.



M1: 45,5°C, M2: 48,6°C, M3: 46,7°C, M4: 44,9°C, M5: 43,5°C, M6: 49,1°C, M7: 39,2°C, HS1: 52,7°C
These photos are done with a 2600mA charge, i.e. things will get hot, but it is not that bad.
At lower charge current everything will be cooler



M1: 47,9°C, M2: 51,4°C, M3: 40,4°C, HS1: 65,4°C
The fan is blowing some hot air out the bottom of the charger, look at the table temperature.



Charging with lowest current setting. The charger uses a 3A pulse, but for a very short time.



Increasing the charge current to 2A will increase the pulse with.



When starting on a charge the charger will first use a 3A pulse for about 8 seconds, then switch to regular charge.



The top-off charge is with 68ms wide 3A pulses, this gives an average current of 100mA.



Trickle charge uses the same 3A pulses, they are just shorter at 33ms every other second, this gives an average current of around 50mA, not the 10mA shown in the application.



The charger can detect a full battery very fast.



NiMH discharge

Discharge between 100mA and 1000mA must be selected.



The charger discharges to 0.9 on its default setting.
Display shows 2155mAh



I wonder a bit about the jumps in temperature, they must be related to the fan control.



Discharging four cells will warm the batteries a bit, but not much.
Display shows 1862mAh, 1868mAh, 1904mAh, 1833mAh



M1: 33,8°C, M2: 36,4°C, M3: 35,3°C, M4: 33,6°C, M5: 35,8°C, M6: 34,0°C, HS1: 50,7°C
Discharge temperature are not that hot, the fan is keeping it cool.



The discharge is also done with pwm, here the lowest setting.



And here the highest setting.



NiMH cycle

Charge rate between 200mA and 2600mA, discharge between 100mA and 1000mA and number of cycles between 1 and 12 must be selected. Between each charge and discharge it rest for 1 hour.
Both first and last operation is a charge.




Here I have specified 3 cycles with 1000mA charge and 1000mA discharge.
Notice that the charger does not use top-off or trickle charge between cycles, it is only used after the last charge.
Display shows 1841mAh, 1859mAh, 1847mAh



NiMH break-in

Capacity must be selected from 500mAh to 3500Ah.
Break-in charges with 0.1C for 16 hours, rest one hour, discharges with 0.2C, rest one hour and then charges again with 0.1C for 16 hours.
This means the total time is about 16+1+5+1+16 -\> 39 hours or 2340 minutes.



This matches with the curve I recorded. I specified a 2000mAh battery, meaning 200mA charge and 400mA discharge.
I wonder why the charger uses a top off charge here, it is definitely not needed.
Display shows 3199mAh, not really a useful value.



NiMH refresh

Charge rate between 200mA and 2600mA and discharge between 100mA and 1000mA must be selected.
Refresh does one charge, discharge, charge cycle with adjustable currents for both charge and discharge.



Here I have specified 1000mA charge and 1000mA discharge.
Display shows 2079mAh



USB output

One obvious way to use this output is to keep the phone/tablet powered while it is logging.
  • USB output is coded as Sony, except Sony do not use this coding anymore.

  • USB output requires charger is powered.





The output is rated for 2.1A and can easily deliver that.



At least for 24 minutes, then it shuts down.



Testing again with 1.8A load and I could get the full hour.



At 0.5A the noise is 14mV rms and 78mVpp.



At 1A the noise is 15mV rms and 106mVpp.



At full 2A load the noise is 12mV rms and 113Vpp, all the noise figures are very good.


Testing with 2830 volt and 4242 volt between mains and low volt side, did not show any safety problems.



Conclusion

Like other analyzing charger it has many functions and a range of currents.
I was not very impressed with the termination at low current, it looks like the -dv/dt value is a bit high. If the application had worked on my phone I could have fixed that (At least for 0.5A).
I would also have like to get rid of the top-off charge and trickle charge.

Current and noise on the usb output is fairly good, but it output could be improved by using a standard DCP coding or a auto coding chip.

The charger is fairly good without the application, but if the application had worked it would have been better.



Notes

The variations in the average current is probably due to interference between my sample rate and the chargers pwm rate.
The scope images may show too low a current, because I uses a 0.1ohm resistor in series with the battery to measure current.
The charger was supplied by Gearbest for review.

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger

Read more about how I test USB power supplies and chargers

Due to this NC2600 is a discontinued product, it has a good price, so I’ve just bought one, 70 EUR shipping cost included.

I’ve only found reviews about the NC2600, but not user comments or doubts, so although the charger is old and discontinued, I write my experiences in case someone has also bought it for a good price and has concerns

Regarding the review, the actual Android app v1.96 detects and draws AAA cells, and permits adjust some the extra parameteres not configurable by charger, same as described in the review (app v.1.0 according to pictute). Top-off charge is not configurable. About this, paper received and pdf downloable Manual v1.0 (2016-06) are outdated about this (tricke charge is not included as configurable parametres in specifications and in the app chapter of the manual)

I’ve had not any problem to connect NC2600 and app by means of bluetooth (tested with Android 6 and 9 in two LG smartphones). First a bluetooth search and 0000 match code is required in the smartphone to connect, after this the app finds charger. All parameters can be seen in the smartphone, including the extra temperature and internal resistance not shown in the charger.

The only and important problem with the app is when process finishes to ‘DONE’, I find the charger is disconnected from the app, so there’s no possibility of watching V - t final graphic. I don’t get to reactivate bluetooth in the charger, smartphone bluetooth can’t find it, so I understand is a normal charger behavior, but I’d rather it wasn’t.

With all that happy with the purchase

Regards

About the HKJ’s small programming guide at the end of MC3000 review, would be valid these points for NC2600:

- Charge current over 0.3C for not to miss termination on AA/AAA cells.

- Parameter -dv/dt as low as possible is better, even too low will not damage the cell, only might give early termination.
(I’ve tried the 8 mV by defect value with a 0,2C charge current, and really it’s a ‘never ending charging’)

- Trickle charge to ‘OFF’ for LSD cells

- Discharging Cut-offf Voltage set to 1V (from 0,9V by defect), to match in ‘Break-In’ mode the official IEC 61951-2 (2017) capacity test as described and required in 7.3
(About this some chargers like new Powerex MH-C9000PRO specificates Discharging Cut-offf Voltage 0,9V and a Break-In for capacity mode matching IEC, which is is true if this Break-In mode uses 1,0V…

Other point in Break-In mode, cell must be previously discharged
I comment cause Break-In implies a ‘non intelligent’ charging of 0,1 C during 16 h, what already implies a theoretical a 60% overcharging, but if cell is full at the begining, becomes in 160%.
From my point of view, a Breaking-in mode should start discharging the cell… in fact to a 1V according to IEC 61951-2 in 7.2.1.as procedure prior to charging.

- About Voltage Protection, 1,55 V by defect, I’ve not modified after reading HKJ’s post ‘Battery charging NiMH’, and waiting a good -dv/dt termination.

Regards