Same or even better in throw than white flat 1mm with more lumens and wide screen tv die projection
Edit: Why I said it may be better than white flat 1mm? Because I can not measure that with mine fet driver configuration since it pulls a lot of current and thus generates a lot of heat which could have influence on performance.
Some regulated configuration in multi cell lights with better cooling potential will show real nature of this emitter.
If I would have to place a bet who would win between 1mm or 2mm White Flat I would place a bet on this new White Flat 2 mm.
Since it is not suitable for my fet driver single 18650 light configuration I am really looking forward for real builds BLF members will bring with this new White Flat 2mm.
Comparison pic between new White Flat 2mm(sorry I really can’t remember full name) and XP-G2 S4 2B DD
It’s the same LED technology but with just a bigger die.
Since the physical size is the same it will always perform worse than the smaller emitter because it has a larger die area and therefore requires more wattage to achieve the same cd/mm^2
More watts and same cooling pad area = worse performance as you increase the current.
The boost HX aka CULPM1.TG which has a physically larger size has the chance to perform better.
The datasheet says the die is 1.59:1.25, (1.272:1) which is 12.72:10. Much closer to 4:3 regular tv aspect ratio (1.33:1) than 16:9 widescreen. (1.77:1)
More watts and same cooling pad area = worse performance as you increase the current.
Yes that happens in mine host. But for couple of seconds mine tested White flat 2mm at 9-10A has same or slightly better performance as tested White flat 1mm driven at 5.8A.
There is still that 10% of lux variations that can happen between emitters so if you got worse 1mm and better 2mm wf could actually win imho.
So this is obviously emitter for someone like you Enderman. Better cooling methods etc… Really don’t know why you don’t have wish to try it. You will have to wait for a long time until HX appears
More watts and same cooling pad area = worse performance as you increase the current.
Yes that happens in mine host. But for couple of seconds mine tested White flat 2mm at 9-10A has same or slightly better performance as tested White flat 1mm driven at 5.8A.
There is still that 10% of lux variations that can happen between emitters so if you got worse 1mm and better 2mm wf could actually win imho.
So this is obviously emitter for someone like you Enderman. Better cooling methods etc… Really don’t know why you don’t have wish to try it. You will have to wait for a long time until HX appears
The transient temperature response will be completely different for both LEDs.
The reason the 1mm is getting worse performance is probably because 5.8A is past the peak of the output curve, while the 2mm is still not at its peak at 9-10A.
The proper way to compare them is to put them on a proper CPU heatsink, make current-output curves to find the peak of the curve (at steady state obviously, not only after a few seconds), and then compare the peak luminance at those peaks.
Once the post strike in canada finished I will immediately buy a few CSLPM1.TGs to test and I’ll show you what I mean.
I have no idea how this project product compares to crystals, sintered phosphor, etc. PDF claims it has taken 445nm laser powers up to 30W/mm2 on metal and on glass substrates. Has 96CRI at 5500K tint option. Seems like it would be handy for replacing damage phosphor layers on flip chip LED’s.
The crystals have basically no drop in output till 300C This means you can have a pretty intense laser directed at it without damage. One university tested up to 14W of blue laser and got 4000lm but it was spread over a large 5mm crystal IIRC, not all in a concentrated spot. The crystal was not heatsinked to anything either. These are my main resources: https://www.osapublishing.org/oe/abstract.cfm?uri=oe-24-2-a215http://jss.ecsdl.org/content/5/10/R172.full
The_Driver, could you please add Lumileds Luxeon CZ to the table?
It seems to have the lowest thermal resistance of any 1 mm² LEDs that I’ve seen. Though I’m not sure if they mean real or electrical resistance, the datasheet is unclear about that. If that’s electrical – it’s still very good but no longer special.
Though then there’s a tiny thermal pad which will spoil performance for sure. If indium solder really brings actual improvements, these are going to be relatively high with this LED.
ADDED: This Luxeon C document (not CZ) makes me believe they mean electrical resistance. I’m not really surprised….still, resistance is good and I think this LED should easily get intense enough to deserve a its place in the table on the first page.
I’m not too adept at reading datasheets to determine such things though.
I’m not that great at Datasheets either. But it seems to have package size just a bit bigger than XP, and die size about the same as OSRAM White Flat. It is rated for 385lm from 3.0V and 1.0A current. I’d like to see djozz test it!
—
The Cycle of Goodness: “No one prospers without rendering benefit to others”
- The YKK Philosophy
Peak could be anywhere between 8-10A but it will easily pull over 13A without exploding on fet driver
I did some classic redneck style test here
I like it. Wide screen TV 16:9 format LED emitter
Wow, it pulled 13A with a single cell? That is an impressively low Vf, even the 219C 90cri only pulled around 10-11A.
How does it compare to the flat black / flat white in throw?
Texas Avenger Driver Series
My LED Test series - XP-L2 V5 - Nichia 219C 90+ CRI - Latticebright "XM-L" - XHP35 & PWM efficiency - XHP50 - XP-L V5 - XM-L2 U2 - XP-G3 S5 - XP-L HI V2 - Oslon Square & direct comparison to Djozz tests - Nichia 319A - Nichia 219B 9080 CRI - Nichia 219C D320 - Nichia 229AT - XHP70.2 P2 - XHP50.2 J4 - Samsung LH351D
Easy comparison tool for all my LED tests
Same or even better in throw than white flat 1mm with more lumens and wide screen tv die projection
Edit: Why I said it may be better than white flat 1mm? Because I can not measure that with mine fet driver configuration since it pulls a lot of current and thus generates a lot of heat which could have influence on performance.
Some regulated configuration in multi cell lights with better cooling potential will show real nature of this emitter.
If I would have to place a bet who would win between 1mm or 2mm White Flat I would place a bet on this new White Flat 2 mm.
Since it is not suitable for my fet driver single 18650 light configuration I am really looking forward for real builds BLF members will bring with this new White Flat 2mm.
Comparison pic between new White Flat 2mm(sorry I really can’t remember full name) and XP-G2 S4 2B DD
It’s the same LED technology but with just a bigger die.
Since the physical size is the same it will always perform worse than the smaller emitter because it has a larger die area and therefore requires more wattage to achieve the same cd/mm^2
More watts and same cooling pad area = worse performance as you increase the current.
The boost HX aka CULPM1.TG which has a physically larger size has the chance to perform better.
The OPTOFIRE - 4.63Mcd aspheric LED flashlight The SYNIOSBEAM - 10Mcd recoil LED flashlight List of the farthest throwing flashlights
The datasheet says the die is 1.59:1.25, (1.272:1) which is 12.72:10. Much closer to 4:3 regular tv aspect ratio (1.33:1) than 16:9 widescreen. (1.77:1)
- LEDs & Other Stuff - - UI CheatSheets - - CRX Flashlight Builds - - CRX Stuff for Sale -
Maybe reason is this?:
http://budgetlightforum.com/node/63638
led4power.com
I am not able to keep up with the latest developments in LED tech now days. If ya’ll find the “perfect throw king” LED let me know.
I have a few lights that might work well with a super thrower LED like these if they pan out.
Texas Avenger Driver Series
My LED Test series - XP-L2 V5 - Nichia 219C 90+ CRI - Latticebright "XM-L" - XHP35 & PWM efficiency - XHP50 - XP-L V5 - XM-L2 U2 - XP-G3 S5 - XP-L HI V2 - Oslon Square & direct comparison to Djozz tests - Nichia 319A - Nichia 219B 9080 CRI - Nichia 219C D320 - Nichia 229AT - XHP70.2 P2 - XHP50.2 J4 - Samsung LH351D
Easy comparison tool for all my LED tests
Yeah probably.
Some of my international packages came in, others no.
It will just take a long while, not your fault.
The OPTOFIRE - 4.63Mcd aspheric LED flashlight The SYNIOSBEAM - 10Mcd recoil LED flashlight List of the farthest throwing flashlights
Yes that happens in mine host. But for couple of seconds mine tested White flat 2mm at 9-10A has same or slightly better performance as tested White flat 1mm driven at 5.8A.
There is still that 10% of lux variations that can happen between emitters so if you got worse 1mm and better 2mm wf could actually win imho.
So this is obviously emitter for someone like you Enderman. Better cooling methods etc… Really don’t know why you don’t have wish to try it. You will have to wait for a long time until HX appears
The transient temperature response will be completely different for both LEDs.
The reason the 1mm is getting worse performance is probably because 5.8A is past the peak of the output curve, while the 2mm is still not at its peak at 9-10A.
The proper way to compare them is to put them on a proper CPU heatsink, make current-output curves to find the peak of the curve (at steady state obviously, not only after a few seconds), and then compare the peak luminance at those peaks.
Once the post strike in canada finished I will immediately buy a few CSLPM1.TGs to test and I’ll show you what I mean.
The OPTOFIRE - 4.63Mcd aspheric LED flashlight The SYNIOSBEAM - 10Mcd recoil LED flashlight List of the farthest throwing flashlights
XP-E2(the best version is torch i think) is beaten by larger brother XP-G2?
Imho there are plenty of stuff that can strike us like bad re flow, bad emitter pick, thermal path, so you never can be 100% sure…
I will place bet on 2mm version anyway.
Looking forward for your test.
I have added the new Osram LEDs. The thermal resistance of the Boost HX shows why it will probably be way better than all the others.
Project Excalibur - Next Generation LED Thrower (UPDATE 2018-01-15: 1.7Mcd)
Portable Thrower Comparison
I have no idea how this
projectproduct compares to crystals, sintered phosphor, etc. PDF claims it has taken 445nm laser powers up to 30W/mm2 on metal and on glass substrates. Has 96CRI at 5500K tint option. Seems like it would be handy for replacing damage phosphor layers on flip chip LED’s.https://phosphortech.com/datasheets/datasheet-phosphor-sheets.pdf
Does anybody have anything on the Boost HX recently?
Any one going to add the info on the SST20?
Light Reviews
Cheap Flashlight Durability Test
Convoy S2+ Written review
Brinyte T16 Artemis tear down
YouTube Reviews
Sofirn D25S Review
Xmund XD-FL3 Review
World band shortwave radio review
Mods and Builds
6th Annual Old Lumens Scratch build entry
7th annual Old Lumens scratch build entry
The_Driver, could you please add Lumileds Luxeon CZ to the table?
It seems to have the lowest thermal resistance of any 1 mm² LEDs that I’ve seen. Though I’m not sure if they mean real or electrical resistance, the datasheet is unclear about that. If that’s electrical – it’s still very good but no longer special.
Though then there’s a tiny thermal pad which will spoil performance for sure. If indium solder really brings actual improvements, these are going to be relatively high with this LED.
ADDED: This Luxeon C document (not CZ) makes me believe they mean electrical resistance. I’m not really surprised….still, resistance is good and I think this LED should easily get intense enough to deserve a its place in the table on the first page.
I have added it, maybe you can help me fill some of the data fields.
I’m very sceptical regarding the maximum performance.
Project Excalibur - Next Generation LED Thrower (UPDATE 2018-01-15: 1.7Mcd)
Portable Thrower Comparison
I don’t expect it to play in the same league as automotive LEDs really.
But:
And I think it’s likely to be the throwiest LED on the market with CRI>70.
Area of the heat conducting solder pad:
1.08 mm²
max. rated LED temperature Tj:
135°C
Other fields need testing.
Luminus SST-20 CRI95 seems to be over 100 cd/mm² though the precision of my calculations is too low to call it definitive:
http://budgetlightforum.com/comment/1508827#comment-1508827
CRI70 variant is over 100 for sure. I’m sure I’ve see it tested somewhere but can’t find it now….
.
led4power.com
Boost HX or colored flat?
Looks like 1 mm²!!??
Haven’t heard about it before but CULNM1.TG is a thing:
https://www.arrow.com/en/products/kw-culnm1.tg-z8pf5-ebvffcbb46-65g5/osr...
ADDED:
And Osram is phasing it out:
https://www.mouser.com/PCN/Osram_Opto_Semiconductor_1_cip_OS_NFND_2018_0...
4040-size and 1mm2 die, hmmm
link to djozz tests
Throw the bone to the dogs L4P
It looks like 2mm2 led to me… But lets wait and see what will L4P say.
1 mm², CULNM1.TG aka Boost HL. And it’s already tested:
http://budgetlightforum.com/comment/1509652#comment-1509652
Than it seems we spammed The Drivers thread
I already added it and linked to the test.
Project Excalibur - Next Generation LED Thrower (UPDATE 2018-01-15: 1.7Mcd)
Portable Thrower Comparison
I’m guessing this is nothing too interesting:
https://www.samsung.com/led/automotive/automotive-leds/i-series/3w-white/
I’m not too adept at reading datasheets to determine such things though.
I’m not that great at Datasheets either. But it seems to have package size just a bit bigger than XP, and die size about the same as OSRAM White Flat. It is rated for 385lm from 3.0V and 1.0A current. I’d like to see djozz test it!
The Cycle of Goodness: “No one prospers without rendering benefit to others”
- The YKK Philosophy
Pages