1800k handheld foglight - which host and emitter to choose?

I’m trying to come up with a pleasant configuration for a dedicated foglight.
 

Goals:

  • Narrow beam to reduce backscatter
  • warm temperature, probably 1800k, also to reduce backscatter
  • rosy tint (because I find green mixed with orange/amber far worse than white with a hint of green)
  • sustained output of 1000+ lumens for 1-1.5 hrs (flexible if the beam is intense enough)
  • throw of ~120 meters or better
  • doesn’t hit uncomfortable temperatures for its best sustained output level
  • not gigantic because otherwise I mostly won’t use it.
  • Hi CRI if possible, but not if the tint is bad

Any ideas? I was thinking maybe a Convoy L21B with 519a dedomed but I’m not sure if that would be concentrated enough or bright enough.

1 Thank

Convoy l21a with lhp 73b 1800K and 20A buck driver acompanied with a decent cell

Checkout the Fireflies new E12, and the E04 Surge. Or basically any of the FF lights have ultra high CRI 1800k options and they have the best buck/boost drivers.

@Toaster79 @SKV89

Those options you listed are all on the floody side and I’m looking for a narrow beam.

Have you experienced 73b in l21 reflector before?

Not personally but I found a lot of beam-shots and while it does throw far, it also has some pretty strong spill. Normally I’d see this as a feature but not for this particular light.

Noctigon K1 NTG50 1800K

1 Thank

Nice tint! I have an SFT-40 in a smaller reflector (convoy m21f) and this looks floodier than that. I wish Hank offered smaller emitters with the Lume X1 driver in the K1

1 Thank

Something else to consider might be yellow filtered glasses/lenses. I WANT to say it could be a placebo, but I was using my yellow filters the ither night and it took ALOT of the harshness out of what I was seeing.

1 Thank

The Fireflies E90 series is very throwy but might not be pocketable and if you want smaller pocketable size then try the X1S series that is somewhat throwy. If you want throwy, then you need a big head and the light will not be compact.

1 Thank

Probably want a host with big TIR lens to avoid needless scatter (ie, spill from a reflector light).

The IF22A is quite nice…

Has anyone ever opened this light? I tried everything but couldn’t get the bezel to move.

At least the LHP531 in 1800K is very much amber and not warm white!
I would have thrown the M21B into the ring as well? Got somewhat throwy host, with a 519A and an OP reflector it could be the right light.

1 Thank

I never tried. Without knowing how bad it’s glued, if rh/lh threads, etc., I wouldn’t want to chance ruining the finish.

Try to loosen it, and only end up torquing it even tighter, maybe warp the threads, etc. Nah.

1 Thank

I already wear glasses and another pair would NOT be welcome :smiley:

Anyway, I’ve switched back and forth between warm and cool emitters on a really foggy night before and the difference is pretty stark.

1 Thank

My brother has a 519a in an M21B and it’s a nice light but it doesn’t have quite the focused beam I was imagining.

@SKV89 @Lightbringer You guys might be right about the TIR ideas. Or maybe an fresnel lens would be a good idea.

I’ve got clip on lenses

1 Thank

Ah gotcha. Still though, not the approach I would favor.

I had heard that due to wavelength, the warmer beam actually pierces fog better. I should try and find out if that’s scientifically true or not…

1 Thank

I imagine it would reduce backscatter somewhat because of the longer wavelengths. The important thing isn’t solely how much light makes it on target, it’s how much of that light comes back to the eyeballs, so I’m inclined to believe that limiting some frequencies would be similar to cutting back interference noise.

Well, the Google AI overview goes with the longer wavelengths = better theory.

But I found this source that states otherwise:

Interestingly, I accidentally backed away from the search page and reloaded it and this result was missing from the google results despite being at the top before. Weird…

1 Thank