Armytek Wizard Pro mod with Virence E21A 2000K

SKV89 · 2019-05-21T06:01:37.000Z

My Tiara Pro with 4xE21A 2000k measured:
CCT: 2010K
DUV: of –0.0002
CRI: 95.3
R9: 91.3
Rg: 101

Blue light output is on par or less than the 2200k Good Night light bulb that I returned. The Good Night light bulb has a yellow shade that makes everything look yellowish. The Duv was about 0.005. CRI was 90. The E21A looked so much better. I wish someone can make E21A light bulbs. It would beat anything on the market including the SORAA bulbs that I have.

cetary · 2019-05-21T22:31:34.000Z

I ended up running a third party app on my phone to measure CCT. I guess I just got a 2200K sample, but still a gorgeous light. Red wood look so rich under under the light. I was just blown away with how rich it made my wood cutting board and furniture look. I wish they would use LEDs like these in bulbs. I would like to see LED street lights/architectural area lights with these emitters, what wonderful experience it would be to be under this rich light in the city.

xenotar80 · 2019-05-22T02:08:23.000Z

SKV89:

My Tiara Pro with 4xE21A 2000k measured:
CCT: 2010K
DUV: of –0.0002
CRI: 95.3
R9: 91.3
Rg: 101

Blue light output is on par or less than the 2200k Good Night light bulb that I returned. The Good Night light bulb has a yellow shade that makes everything look yellowish. The Duv was about 0.005. CRI was 90. The E21A looked so much better. I wish someone can make E21A light bulbs. It would beat anything on the market including the SORAA bulbs that I have.

yeah i would love it if someone made E21A bulbs. I tried out the soraa healthy a19 bulbs and i hated them. they made me kinda dizzy and had a greenish tint on it. returned immediately. i should figure out how to measure the cct on mine.

xenotar80 · 2019-05-22T02:09:45.000Z

cetary:

I ended up running a third party app on my phone to measure CCT. I guess I just got a 2200K sample, but still a gorgeous light. Red wood look so rich under under the light. I was just blown away with how rich it made my wood cutting board and furniture look. I wish they would use LEDs like these in bulbs. I would like to see LED street lights/architectural area lights with these emitters, what wonderful experience it would be to be under this rich light in the city.

yeah that would be amazing. they changed the street lamps years ago on my street to horrid blue leds. i would love it if they were 2000K.

SKV89 · 2019-05-22T02:25:42.000Z

xenotar80:

SKV89:

My Tiara Pro with 4xE21A 2000k measured:
CCT: 2010K
DUV: of –0.0002
CRI: 95.3
R9: 91.3
Rg: 101

Blue light output is on par or less than the 2200k Good Night light bulb that I returned. The Good Night light bulb has a yellow shade that makes everything look yellowish. The Duv was about 0.005. CRI was 90. The E21A looked so much better. I wish someone can make E21A light bulbs. It would beat anything on the market including the SORAA bulbs that I have.

yeah i would love it if someone made E21A bulbs. I tried out the soraa healthy a19 bulbs and i hated them. they made me kinda dizzy and had a greenish tint on it. returned immediately. i should figure out how to measure the cct on mine.

The SORAA bulbs uses violet emitters instead of blue emitters. Violet has shorter wavelength than blue so it is higher energy, which might be even worst than blue. I’m guessing that’s what might be causing your dizziness. I did measure it to have higher amount of violet wavelength than other light bulbs of the same color temperature.

cetary · 2019-05-22T21:27:24.000Z

xenotar80:

yeah that would be amazing. they changed the street lamps years ago on my street to horrid blue leds. i would love it if they were 2000K.

Maybe not a perfect 2000K, but Chicago is beginning to test the 2200K Lumican LED street light. They had show on it someone posted to Facebook. The color I found is hard to get right on camera. Pittsburgh as well should be trailing the 2200K Lumican. They are testing all lights 2700K or less. The Lumican can be had in color temperatures as low as 1750K with around a 70 CRI, nearly the same level of warmth as LPS/SOX, but with much higher color rendering. It’s a trippy experience.

iamlucky13 · 2019-05-22T22:30:55.000Z

xenotar80:

yeah i would love it if someone made E21A bulbs. I tried out the soraa healthy a19 bulbs and i hated them. they made me kinda dizzy and had a greenish tint on it. returned immediately. i should figure out how to measure the cct on mine.

I don’t think Healthy is the product line you want if the priority is CRI and tint. Their product page indicates that uses a violet emitter and has a big gap in the spectrum to minimize output in the range with the most potential for sleep disruption. Radiant should be the line most people want. I think Radiant also uses violet emitters to maximize color rendering, but without skipping the blue tones.

However, yes, it would be awesome to be able to buy household lights using some of the best emitters now available, like E21a or Optisolis.

The Yuji A19 bulbs should be great, but they aren’t quite omnidirectional, and they’re even more expensive than the Soraa bulbs.

iamlucky13 · 2019-05-22T22:34:07.000Z

xenotar80:

yeah that would be amazing. they changed the street lamps years ago on my street to horrid blue leds. i would love it if they were 2000K.

To be honest, I don’t think I’d want that warm for general lighting, even in residential areas.

But definitely not the harsh cool whites they’re using in most places. I think I’m fortunate in that most of the streetlights around my area look like they’re in the 4500-5000K range.

I’m fine with that on the major highways, but in residential areas, I’d much prefer they stay below 3500K.

cetary · 2019-05-22T23:16:46.000Z

iamlucky13:

To be honest, I don’t think I’d want that warm for general lighting, even in residential areas.

But definitely not the harsh cool whites they’re using in most places. I think I’m fortunate in that most of the streetlights around my area look like they’re in the 4500-5000K range.

I’m fine with that on the major highways, but in residential areas, I’d much prefer they stay below 3500K.

Unfortunately, 3500K, 4500K, and 5000K, are all way beyond AMA guidance for outdoor lighting. Those color temperatures of light suppress melatonin and leptin leading to multiple health implications. The sleep aspect regarding blue rich LEDs has been addressed .

Regarding those LED street lights listed above 3000K.

“High-intensity LED lighting designs emit a large amount of blue light that appears white to the naked eye and create worse nighttime glare than conventional lighting. Discomfort and disability from intense, blue-rich LED lighting can decrease visual acuity and safety, resulting in concerns and creating a road hazard.”

From Harvard regarding the implications with obesity …

“A Harvard study shed a little bit of light on the possible connection to diabetes and possibly obesity. The researchers put 10 people on a schedule that gradually shifted the timing of their circadian rhythms. Their blood sugar levels increased, throwing them into a prediabetic state, and levels of leptin, a hormone that leaves people feeling full after a meal, went down.”

There are further peer reviewed studies that are coming to similar conclusions. Light above 3000K doesn’t belong anywhere lighting our streets at night. Further, studies conducted in Davis, CA showed that people were nearly 20-1 against the original 4000K fixtures. Their early implementation of warm white LED street lights indicated that even 3000K was too high, and that eventually LED them to a custom order of 2700K Leotek Green Cobra Jr.s’. 2700K should really be the maximum permitted in residential areas with 3000K/2700K reserved more for the larger streets.

The EU, as well, their, outdoor lighting guidance for roadways calls for 3000K max with warmer color temperatures having relaxed efficiency standards thus passively encouraging better light.

Also, I would be really careful about using voilet pump emitters. These Soraa lights were tested by Dr. Travis Longcore as having substantially greater negative impacts on wildlife then most warm white light sources that included warm white blue-pump LED, metal halide, and CFL, and even higher CCT cool white LED street lights.

iamlucky13 · 2019-05-23T02:55:43.000Z

cetary:

iamlucky13:

To be honest, I don’t think I’d want that warm for general lighting, even in residential areas.

But definitely not the harsh cool whites they’re using in most places. I think I’m fortunate in that most of the streetlights around my area look like they’re in the 4500-5000K range.

I’m fine with that on the major highways, but in residential areas, I’d much prefer they stay below 3500K.

Unfortunately, 3500K, 4500K, and 5000K, are all way beyond AMA guidance for outdoor lighting. Those color temperatures of light suppress melatonin and leptin leading to multiple health implications. The sleep aspect regarding blue rich LEDs has been addressed .

Luminous intensity is even more important than color temperature, which the AMA guidance acknowledges, but unfortunately did not discuss. Frankly, the references cited in the AMA list were a bit disappointing in how high the ratio of mainstream media articles was compared to actual research papers. It’s not that the AMA guidance is wrong. It’s just really limited in its utility due to the limited depth and breadth of research it relied on.

One study that does look in a very cursory manner at intensity vs. color temperature is here:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0003687016301582?via%3Dihub

Basically, low intensity (0.1 lux) 2700K light was their control, and all higher intensity (200 lux) test cases even down to 1600K exhibited more melatonin suppression. I don’t have a lower limit of significant effect handy, but that factor has been more studied in isolation, and a decent figure probably determined. The impression I get is it is somewhere below 10 lux for incandescents, which actually is quite a bit of light, but I don’t know how far below.

Also, I think it’s well worth discriminating between high traffic highway lights not in close proximity to residences versus and those that are in proximity and illuminate low traffic areas, because we have to keep in mind the reason those lights are there, which is safety. More neutral lighting, compared to warm tones, provides better alertness and acuity, and depending on the colors of objects illuminated, can provide significantly better object discrimination and perception. So I suggest that using neutral white lighting in areas where it has a low potential to effect circadian rhythms is prudent.

I don’t see much reason to use violet-pumped LED’s outdoors. It’s just not an application where I see a need to chase the best CRI possible, so the conclusions you reference of Dr. Longcore seem reasonably easy to abide by. From what I’m seeing, his research seems mostly relevant to critically sensitive areas, like sea turtle hatching grounds, where users are being encouraged to use amber or red lights.

iamlucky13 · 2019-05-23T03:01:00.000Z

Also, I apologize, I just realized we’re getting rather far off topic for a thread about Armytek Wizards.

I’m enjoying seeing these mods, and am hoping to do my own Armytek E21A mod before too long. Mine will likely be 3500K.

I also want to try out a good 2000K light, so I think I’m going to mod one of my Fenix E05’s with an E21A. Clemence indicated his Jetbeam Jet-u kit is also compatible with the E05.

xenotar80 · 2019-05-23T03:52:19.000Z

cetary:

Also, I would be really careful about using voilet pump emitters. These Soraa lights were tested by Dr. Travis Longcore as having substantially greater negative impacts on wildlife then most warm white light sources that included warm white blue-pump LED, metal halide, and CFL, and even higher CCT cool white LED street lights.

that’s good to know. i’ll stay away from soraa lights that are violet shifted. i wonder if anyone has made their own light bulbs in e21a at 2000K… i’d want to make some of those. it’s annoying to change halogens so often, but the light is so nice from halogens.

SKV89 · 2019-05-23T03:54:27.000Z

I didn’t like the E21A 2000k the first few times I turned it on because I thought it was too yellow. A few months later, I turned it on late at night and I actually started to really like it. It didn’t make everything yellow and felt very warm and cozy. I realize it just takes time for your eyes to adjust to the color temperature. No I modded a bunch of small lights with the E21A 2000k for night time use by family members. I also bring them to hotels and leave them on throughout the night as night light for bathroom visits.

xenotar80 · 2019-05-23T03:57:59.000Z

iamlucky13:

Also, I apologize, I just realized we’re getting rather far off topic for a thread about Armytek Wizards.

I’m enjoying seeing these mods, and am hoping to do my own Armytek E21A mod before too long. Mine will likely be 3500K.

I also want to try out a good 2000K light, so I think I’m going to mod one of my Fenix E05’s with an E21A. Clemence indicated his Jetbeam Jet-u kit is also compatible with the E05.

it’s not that far off topic, i enjoyed reading the responses. modding is fun and i need to try out more.

i really want to figure out if i can make an a19 and br30 light bulb with e21a in 2000K

xenotar80 · 2019-05-23T03:59:12.000Z

SKV89:

I didn’t like the E21A 2000k the first few times I turned it on because I thought it was too yellow. A few months later, I turned it on late at night and I actually started to really like it. It didn’t make everything yellow and felt very warm and cozy. I realize it just takes time for your eyes to adjust to the color temperature. No I modded a bunch of small lights with the E21A 2000k for night time use by family members. I also bring them to hotels and leave them on throughout the night as night light for bathroom visits.

yes! i’m modding all of my lights so my family members can use them too. glad you warmed up to the 2000K

cetary · 2019-05-23T16:13:31.000Z

iamlucky13:

Luminous intensity is even more important than color temperature, which the AMA guidance acknowledges…

From the AMA guidance directly. While color temperature is an imperfect metric to measure blue, it is what we have for now. The issue here is blue color content, and that higher color temperature LEDs emit unhealthy levels of blue when used in outdoor lighting at night.

“AMA encourages communities to minimize and control blue-rich environmental lighting by using the lowest emission of blue light possible to reduce glare. ”

And regarding intensity

“The AMA also recommends all LED lighting should be properly shielded to minimize glare and detrimental human health and environmental effects, and consideration should be given to utilize the ability of LED lighting to be dimmed for off-peak time periods.”

iamlucky13:

It’s not that the AMA guidance is wrong. It’s just really limited in its utility due to the limited depth and breadth of research it relied on.

Regarding research, from Dr. Mario Motta, one of the co-authors of the AMA guidance.

“In 2012, knowing the research activities of many scientists from around world on the effects of nighttime lighting on human physiology, I invited four prominent researchers to help me write a Council on Science and Public Health (CSAPH) report, “Light Pollution: Adverse Health Effects of Nighttime Lighting.” This 27-page report with 134 peer-reviewed references highlighted the adverse health effects of circadian rhythm disturbance. Suppressing melatonin production through excessive night lighting…”

mariomottamd.com

Street Lighting -

Certainly 30 years ago I was most interested in the sky glow that affects our view of the starry night, and though that remains a major concern, there are now many medical, safety, and environmental concerns that are paramount.

Est. reading time: 9 minutes

Basically, low intensity (0.1 lux) 2700K light was their control, and all higher intensity (200 lux) test cases even down to 1600K exhibited more melatonin suppression.

Quoted from the abstract of your own source…

“Melatonin synthesis was tested with weekly intervals in 8 trials from 10pm to 2am (7 polychromatic illuminations and a dim light reference (<0.1 lx)) in 16 students (9 men, semi-recumbent position). Melatonin suppression was almost negligible for CCT <2000 K but increased with increasing CCT…”

CREEXHP70LED · 2019-05-29T17:04:18.000Z

And then there is this… Along with Space X and other companies sending 20,000 5G satellites into orbit and millions of 5G poles outside your window. 5G LED street lights are here…culling the population.

Ryzbor · 2019-09-20T09:13:32.000Z

SKV89:

My Tiara Pro with 4xE21A 2000k measured:
CCT: 2010K
DUV: of –0.0002
CRI: 95.3
R9: 91.3
Rg: 101

On which power level where these measurements taken?

SKV89 · 2019-09-20T18:22:51.000Z

It’s the same at all levels. One of the most consistent lights I have ever seen.

Ryzbor · 2019-09-26T09:55:11.000Z

Isn’t that impossible?

I want a 2000K E21A Wizard Pro now.