First off, welcome to BLF! :partying_face:

Now, I do not recommend a C8 format light of any kind as an “all rounder”, let alone with an XP-L HI. Far too throwy for indoors usage, and bulky as well. The S2+ is on the other end of the spectrum, floody and compact but will leave you hanging in wide open spaces unless you put a 10 degree TIR on it or something, and then it’ll have the same trouble as the C8 beam-wise.

For balance, my opinion is that the Convoy M1 with Biscotti is a no-brainer. Decent spill and fairly tight spot, plus a format that’s not too big to pocket. I have one in 7A warm white that serves me nicely, though you might want it in a more neutral tint like 3B or 4C.