Best pocket 18650 thrower?

Yoordie · 2019-03-30T07:14:29.000Z

Macka17:

Yoordie.
Get some “wrangler” jeans. then you can wear in comfort AND carry a C8+ or several other torches in there with room to spare.

I’m fine with my jeans

Yoordie · 2019-03-30T07:16:41.000Z

toddcshoe:

I’d just grab the Convoy M2 with XP-L Hi in it. Has the biscotti driver already installed and a nice throwy emitter and SMO reflector. Pick your tint and shine on my friend.

22.49€ |Convoy M1 XPL HALLO LED, DTP platte, 7135*8 biscotti, glatte reflektor, 18650 taschenlampe, taschenlampe|Taschenlampen| - AliExpress

I was already thinking about buying this one, but it is a little bit thicker. I’ll look up some reviews.

robo819 · 2019-03-30T07:18:01.000Z

Something I have not seen mentioned , that to me is a great little thrower for the size (310 meters ANSI rated and 2100 lumens) and also serves as a headlamp / EDC (comes with a clip as well as headband) is the Thrunite TH10 V2. It is a single 18650 with XHP 35 HI emitter and smooth reflector.

My full review with charts , beamshots and live outdoor comparisons …… HERE

Yoordie · 2019-03-30T07:20:03.000Z

Tumbleweed48:

Anytime somebody says ‘best’ I cringe a little, but ‘very good’ at a very affordable price would be a standard S2 Convoy with an inexpensive smooth reflector and an XP-L Hi emitter in the flavour of your choice.

Pot it well with some of those squishy little cubes from Intl-Outdoors, drive it at a humble 3 amps or so, and you’ll see it everything you need to see this side of an actual foot long, two pound light sabre.

Slightly better, a bit more bullet proof (but a bit less pocketable), might be a hot-rodded Solarforce P60.

Bottom line? Everyone’s ‘best’ is different, and subject to a whole lot of variables.

The best one for my use case. Everyone has got their opinion and their favorite ofc.

Yoordie · 2019-03-30T07:22:41.000Z

robo819:

Something I have not seen mentioned , that to me is a great little thrower for the size (310 meters ANSI rated and 2100 lumens) and also serves as a headlamp / EDC (comes with a clip as well as headband) is the Thrunite TH10 V2. It is a single 18650 with XHP 35 HI emitter and smooth reflector.

My full review with charts , beamshots and live outdoor comparisons …… HERE

21700 is fine but I don’t like an emitter on the side.

Geuzzz · 2019-03-30T07:30:57.000Z

In unmodded tube format definitely the mh20gt.

Yoordie · 2019-03-30T07:37:49.000Z

Lightbringer:

MH20GT? One of the smallest 18650 lights I got, only slightly wider reflector than most tubelights, but emphasis is on throw even vs the regular MH20 (“GT” = “Greater Throw”).

If you don’t want a big-head light like a GTmini or P30, the MH20GT might suit ya.

But value wise I think the convoy m2 will be better. How does it compare to the m2 and s2+(+).

Yoordie · 2019-03-30T08:13:47.000Z

Yoordie:

Lightbringer:

MH20GT? One of the smallest 18650 lights I got, only slightly wider reflector than most tubelights, but emphasis is on throw even vs the regular MH20 (“GT” = “Greater Throw”).

If you don’t want a big-head light like a GTmini or P30, the MH20GT might suit ya.

But value wise I think the convoy m2 will be better. How does it compare to the m2 and s2+(+).

And what about the sofirn sf36w

4492011 · 2019-03-30T13:05:15.000Z

Yoordie:

Yoordie:

Lightbringer:

MH20GT? One of the smallest 18650 lights I got, only slightly wider reflector than most tubelights, but emphasis is on throw even vs the regular MH20 (“GT” = “Greater Throw”).

If you don’t want a big-head light like a GTmini or P30, the MH20GT might suit ya.

But value wise I think the convoy m2 will be better. How does it compare to the m2 and s2+(+).

And what about the sofirn sf36w

It is the same size as the Convoy M2 different emitter, the M2 will have a better throw with the XPL-HI also has a little deeper reflector great light, head is larger than S2+

Yoordie · 2019-03-30T13:32:55.000Z

4492011:

Yoordie:

Yoordie:

Lightbringer:

MH20GT? One of the smallest 18650 lights I got, only slightly wider reflector than most tubelights, but emphasis is on throw even vs the regular MH20 (“GT” = “Greater Throw”).

If you don’t want a big-head light like a GTmini or P30, the MH20GT might suit ya.

But value wise I think the convoy m2 will be better. How does it compare to the m2 and s2+(+).

And what about the sofirn sf36w

It is the same size as the Convoy M2 different emitter, the M2 will have a better throw with the XPL-HI also has a little deeper reflector great light, head is larger than S2+

I did some test and I think about 25 mm really is my limit when it comes to the thickness.

4492011 · 2019-03-30T13:43:22.000Z

Yoordie:

4492011:

Yoordie:

Yoordie:

Lightbringer:

MH20GT? One of the smallest 18650 lights I got, only slightly wider reflector than most tubelights, but emphasis is on throw even vs the regular MH20 (“GT” = “Greater Throw”).

If you don’t want a big-head light like a GTmini or P30, the MH20GT might suit ya.

But value wise I think the convoy m2 will be better. How does it compare to the m2 and s2+(+).

And what about the sofirn sf36w

It is the same size as the Convoy M2 different emitter, the M2 will have a better throw with the XPL-HI also has a little deeper reflector great light, head is larger than S2+

I did some test and I think about 25 mm really is my limit when it comes to the thickness.

The M2 is about 31mm, for 25mm better stick with the tube lights like S2+

Yoordie · 2019-03-30T13:54:12.000Z

4492011:

Yoordie:

4492011:

Yoordie:

Yoordie:

Lightbringer:

MH20GT? One of the smallest 18650 lights I got, only slightly wider reflector than most tubelights, but emphasis is on throw even vs the regular MH20 (“GT” = “Greater Throw”).

If you don’t want a big-head light like a GTmini or P30, the MH20GT might suit ya.

But value wise I think the convoy m2 will be better. How does it compare to the m2 and s2+(+).

And what about the sofirn sf36w

It is the same size as the Convoy M2 different emitter, the M2 will have a better throw with the XPL-HI also has a little deeper reflector great light, head is larger than S2+

I did some test and I think about 25 mm really is my limit when it comes to the thickness.

The M2 is about 31mm, for 25mm better stick with the tube lights like S2+

Yeah, I was just looking up the dimensions. Tube light are the way to go.

AllecMn · 2019-03-30T14:06:08.000Z

Yoordie, “Which is the best? Do you have any other suggestions for a different flashlight?”

Here is a photo review for Convoy C8+ - https://forum.guns.ru/forummessage/234/2356363-0.html
You don’t need a text, see only photos and I hope that will help you.
Price history for this item Convoy C8 Cree XML2 U2-1A Led Zaklamp, Zaklamp, Lantaarn, Lanterna Fiets, Zelfverdediging,. The price is very stable.

ValuseekeR · 2019-03-30T15:06:59.000Z

I’ve dithered around on this topic myself for a while, but haven’t bought anything new yet.

GT Mini, Emisar D1s, Thrunite Catapult V6, C8+ and other Convoys, various Sofirns, etc… All look like nice lights, but I’m not sure any of them would get more use than the S2+ (I have 3,) especially in terms of being pocketable.

I do already have a couple of Sofirn SF36’s. Fantastic budgets lights for the price I paid and fairly throwy, but even those are a little bulky for a pants pocket.

Also have the ss BLF X6, which is a gorgeous light, but mainly a shelf queen. A lot of that is the weight, which is why I keep thinking about another compact thrower, but I haven’t been completely sold on anything to this point.

So if you were looking for an unhelpful ramble, there you go.

Yoordie · 2019-03-30T15:25:03.000Z

ValuseekeR:

I’ve dithered around on this topic myself for a while, but haven’t bought anything new yet.

GT Mini, Emisar D1s, Thrunite Catapult V6, C8+ and other Convoys, various Sofirns, etc… All look like nice lights, but I’m not sure any of them would get more use than the S2+ (I have 3,) especially in terms of being pocketable.

I do already have a couple of Sofirn SF36’s. Fantastic budgets lights for the price I paid and fairly throwy, but even those are a little bulky for a pants pocket.

Also have the ss BLF X6, which is a gorgeous light, but mainly a shelf queen. A lot of that is the weight, which is why I keep thinking about another compact thrower, but I haven’t been completely sold on anything to this point.

So if you were looking for an unhelpful ramble, there you go.

I know where you’re coming from mate

Edit: typo

Yoordie · 2019-03-30T22:33:08.000Z

d_t_a:

These beamshots are taken at a ground distance of around 120 meters (flashlight to opposite building), diagonal distance estimated to be around 150 meters or so (400+ feet).

Sofirn SP31 v2.0 (XPL-Hi)

YouTube

Convoy S2 (XPL-Hi 3A neutral-white, 7135x8) [note: this is the S2 with deeper reflector, not S2+]

YouTube

Convoy S2+ (XPL-Hi 4C warm-white, 7135x8)

YouTube

Convoy S2+ (SST20 4000K, warm-white, 7135x8)

YouTube

They look very similar.

gchart · 2019-03-30T23:26:19.000Z

Yoordie:

I did some test and I think about 25 mm really is my limit when it comes to the thickness.

25mm is squarely tube-light territory. Nitecore P12GT is a nice but pricy option (a thinner sibling of the MH20GT). I’m working on a review of the Sofirn SP31 V2.0 - a tube light with XP-L HI. It seems to be a great light so far… smaller than the P12GT, much cheaper, and has 90% of the throw of the P12GT (I measured 17,900 vs 20,150 lux).

d_t_a · 2019-04-08T09:04:30.000Z

Yoordie:

d_t_a:

These beamshots are taken at a ground distance of around 120 meters (flashlight to opposite building), diagonal distance estimated to be around 150 meters or so (400+ feet).

Sofirn SP31 v2.0 (XPL-Hi)

YouTube

Convoy S2 (XPL-Hi 3A neutral-white, 7135x8) [note: this is the S2 with deeper reflector, not S2+]

YouTube

Convoy S2+ (XPL-Hi 4C warm-white, 7135x8)

YouTube

Convoy S2+ (SST20 4000K, warm-white, 7135x8)

YouTube

They look very similar.

From afar, basically the differences are not big, considering they have similar-sized reflector/heads. The Sofirn SP31v2.0 is a bit brighter (confirmed when I use a basic lux meter and do a ceiling bounce test at the same distance).

For instance, using a fully-charge battery, and doing the same ceiling bounce tests, I get these lux readings:
Sofirn SP31 v2.0 (XPL-Hi) : 115 lux
Convoy S2+ XPL-Hi NW (7135x8) : 90 lux
Convoy S2+ SST20-4000K (7135x8) : 60 lux
(lux readings when on max brightness, at the start)

Boaz · 2019-04-08T14:41:39.000Z

I would have guess that the Sofirn sp31 was brighter than the convoy s2+'s too . I was surprised to hear people saying otherwise .The Sp31 is simply a great tube light,nice tint, with a forward clicky on the tail , side switch,bright as hell and works great with an18350 tube and tail magnet to make it a very small very versatile pocket light for about $20 it's hard as hell to beat .

i'm not sure why the OP is having so much difficulty deciding over which tube light to buy if indeed he's willing to spend upwards of 100$ why not just buy 3 of the most recommended and see what you like ? IMHO lights are much more about how it feels in your hand or cri/tint than just output .After years and years of playing with lights it's still very hard to know anything without actually having a light in your hands . it becomes easier but as a noob there's no way for you to know until you try something .

Listen to some good advice .and go with what you like the looks of .be prepared to be wrong .rinse ,lather ,repeat.

Tube lights imho are some of the easiest lights to enjoy ,one of my an N-light L2 .i'm not sure I know anyone else who has one .Ak-47 driver nichia 219A swap Nitecore d-10 clip .< best pocket 18650 tube light I know

Dougiestyle · 2019-04-08T18:50:33.000Z

Form factor of S2, but has better throw… BLF A6. All other suggestions have been different form factor and are rebutted by OP with “S2”, so here we go…

A6 w/ XPL (can be de-domed with novice skills to make it XPL-HI). Add a Carclo 10507 or 10511 TIR optic to aid beam with novice skills while the bezel is off to de-dome. 30min of effort if you stop mid-way to go have a beer.

I’m a BLF newbie, too, but already infected with modumust syndrome.