I don’t know if these links will be of interest to anyone but I thought I’d post them.
While looking into ways to sharpen a straight razor inexpensively I found an alternative to the standard Norton 4k/8k stone which is around $75.
Using this link you can get a two smaller waterstones (4k and 8k) for around $35.
There are inexpensive Chinese 12K polishing stones for around $35 but at www.whippeddog.com you can get one shipped for $15. It’s a quarter of the size of the original but still a good option if you are trying to buy several stones of several grits and want to keep the costs down.
For straight razor honing you typically need 1k,4k,8k, and 12k so using 1k sandpaper (or a more commonly available 1k stone) to set the bevel and the stones listed above for the rest you can inexpensively keep that razor sharp forever.
Some of these stones have uses for knives as well of course so maybe these links will be of use to some of you. I just ran into this info and ordered these items myself.
Goes up to like 50000 ansi grit, not japanese grit. Which is .3 micron. And this site sells them really cheap. They are just super refined sandpaper, so people say they last 2 or 3 dozen sharpenings. Which is great if you aren’t going to be shaving everyday for the rest of your life. Also it’s pretty fast cutting being sandpaper.
Can’t wait till christmas when I get this. Gonna make a small amount sharpenings knifes for people I know too. My friend skins quite a few deer in fall. In fact just skinned 3 today, got payed $150 for it. Only took from noon to 11pm. He said he’d pay 2 or 3 bucks a knife. And a belt sander only takes 5 minutes to go from butter knife dull to hair popping, about a third the time on benchstones. Dad’s wife has a few dozen kitchen knives that are butterknife dull, maybe I’ll ask her if she wants them sharpened. If you go over to knifeforum, all the serious guys use a belt sander of some sort. Though the pros usually use a wider belt with variable belt speeds, those are not economical at all, from a few hundred to thousands of dollars. A wider belt makes less psi, so you don’t grind away metal as fast, letting you control the angle a little more precisely. Custom knifemakers also use belt sanders to create all the bevels and such.
But that’s really interesting to see those smaller stones. Especially since the above 6k grits aren’t used for big knifes, just razors. They really only need a 3 or 4 inch long stone. Some people just like those long stones sometimes. It’s just how I sharpen, but even with a 4 or 5 inch long knife I use only 2 or 3 inches of stone.
I do have the 3M micro films in an assortment pack (micron) 30,9,3,2 and 1.
I use those on a ceramic tile ($.50) from Home Depot. I don’t think they will be useful (for straight razors) more than 2 or 3 times however. They come in large sheets though and I cut them into quarters.
No one uses belt sanders for the final stages of honing a straight razor though
I prefer hand grinding for knives as well but I’m not doing it commercially or in quantity.
Those longer stones are useful with razors as they are quicker but as you mention it is doable with smaller stones.
The longer stones are quicker because you can use longer and uninterrupted strokes. With razors in the final stages you are usually using a lot more strokes than with knives but if you aren’t trying to do it commercially and want to avoid buying a lot of expensive stones that you’ll only need several times a year this is a good option.
Huh, didn’t know they only lasted that long. Lol of course with the belt sander, possibly. Going to a 3k belt, then using a worn out 3k blet(so it’s finer than 3k from being worn down), then a loaded leather belt, then plain leather belt. I’m sure that edge would be quite smooth! But i’ve never tried it that way. Maybe it’s just too easy to round the edge at the low edge angles of a razor. Or because old razors aren’t cheap and they like to use as little metal as little when honing it.
Just googled it and apparently they aren’t used because being such a fine edge and small piece of steel, it ruins the temper on a belt sander.
But then some people say they use them, but with a lower speed. And that wide and long belts help alot.
I’m just getting into this so I’m no expert but basically you strop before every shave and then use a high grit touch-up stone when that’s not working.
So maybe once a week to once a month or longer you give a few passes on a 12k or an 8k. Eventually (maybe once or twice a year) you might go to 4k or 1k to reset the bevel.
When you first buy a razor however (for the most part) it doesn’t come shave ready so you have to set the bevel initially (usually with a 1k). It comes sharp but not shaving sharp.