Comparison Review: tailcapalooza - Solarforce switch extravaganza

As the resident Solarforce whore, I feel it is my duty to compare the more popular tail cap switches from my favorite flashlight company . . . and burden everyone with my opinions. I've also included a few pics of these guys on a flashlight so you can see for yourself if there's an improvement or if you just screwed $15 of ugly onto the end of your prized Solarforce.

Let's start with the first four that I'll call the self-defense group or, how to turn an innocent flashlight into a clothes shredder. From left to right:

S8 $8.99

- forward clicky

- black "HAIII"

- 6061 aluminum

- rated to 3 amps (by Solarforce)

- 14mm boot

- 4 lanyard holes

- will tail stand

This switch is high on the Foy-o-meter because it makes Foy's Masterpiece Pro I look butch. Being larger than the flashlight tube, it gives the fat head Masterpiece needed balance, especially on the longish 2 x 18650 configuration.

S9 $14.99

- forward clicky

- black "HAIII" with stainless steel bezel

- 6061 aluminum

- rated to 3 amps (by Solarforce)

- 14mm boot

- 3 lanyard holes

- will tail stand

Also a Foy favorite simply because it turns any L2 (2011 version) or L2P into a chick magnet. That's right; walk the dog at dusk sporting a new L2, accessorized with the latest tail bling, will increase your odds for some tail. This switch is also larger than the flashlight tube but less so than the S8. It does tail stand and what stability it might lose having three whateveryoucallthem forming the base instead of the usual four, it makes up for with its wider stance.

S11 $11.99

- forward clicky

- black "HAIII" with stainless steel bezel

- 6061 aluminum

- rated to 3 amps (by Solarforce)

- 14mm boot

- 4 lanyard holes

- will tail stand

A favorite for all the above reasons, this switch on an L2P with a Foyed stainless steel bezel is about the best looking flashlight you've ever seen.

S6 $7.99

- black (HAIII)

- 6061 aluminum

- rated to 3 amps (by Solarforce)

- 14mm boot

- 4 lanyard holes

- will tail stand

In appearance, the all black twin to the S11. Not as sexy.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

This group of five are the basic workhorses of the Solarforce P60 family. All but one (the L2T) are reverse clickies and they come standard with their respective hosts. From left to right again:

New L2P $5.50

- reverse clicky

- black "HAIII"

- 6061 aluminum

- 14mm boot

- not drilled for lanyard

- will tail stand

I always thought the standard L2P switch quite handsome but I like this new one too. Compared to the old style; the web site address is less conspicuous, the boot is smaller and the smoothed knurling is ever so slightly more aggressive.

L2P (previous style) not listed

- reverse clicky

- black "HAIII"

- 6061 aluminum

- 16mm boot

- not drilled for lanyard

- will tail stand

See above comments.

New L2 not listed

- reverse clicky

- black

- 6061 aluminum

- 14mm boot

- no provision for lanyard

- will not tail stand

At first glance, this looks like the old L2 switch with improved knurling and a better finish but as you can see, it is somewhat shorter. The old and new L2 tail caps work with either light; Solarforce increased the outside diameter of the flashlight tube to match the cap. An exposed boot like this is sometimes called a "tactical" switch. Whatever you call it, this basic switch gets the job done.

L2 (previous style) $4.50

- reverese clicky

- black (glossy)

- 6061 aluminum

- 14mm boot

- no provision for lanyard

- will not tail stand

Old version - see above.

S10 $7.50 (comes with the L2T)

- forward clicky

- buff black

- 6061 aluminum

- 14mm boot

- no provision for lanyard

- will not tail stand

Similar to the L2 cap, this switch has wider knurling with six vertical lines cut around the side, in keeping with the bezel design of the L2T.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

These four come with their light and are not available separately that I'm aware of. From left to right:

Skyline I

Solarforce calls this their "infinite output system" switch. It's a three mode:

on/off

on-and-hold, until it dims to your liking

double-click, for fast strobe

- 16mm boot

- 2 extended cutouts for lanyard

It will tail stand but the resulting top-heavy Skyline is less stable with the "tactical" cut-outs on two sides of the base. Also, at its lowest setting it has extreme PWM.

L2 (grey, old version)

- reverse clicky

- 6061 aluminum

- 14mm boot

- no provision for lanyard

- same as the black L2

L2i (one silver, one Foyed)

- reverse clicky

- 6061 aluminum

- 14mm boot

- 4 lanyard holes

The L2i caps are male threaded, the same size as the wider L2i body and use the same 14mm boot found on the L2, etc.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

There you have it; all you never wanted to know about Solarforce tail caps. Below, you will find different caps shown on an L2P for comparison.

bubyeFoy

Great pics , as usual .

Colorful , entertaining descriptions , check .

So , you don't like attack bezels but now it seems you've grown fond of attack tailcaps .

Yes.

Foy

Thanks Foy for the great review. But I think you should give one of your tail cap away. So it would not be 13.

This is worthy of being a sticky.

Thanks for the info Foy.

I like the shiny ones. That S9 is gorgeous.

A great read here in the cold Denmark Morning - not least because of the inherent humor.

I best like the S9 too - perhaps that is the one you should gift away - to me ha ha.

foyclick-o-rama! Very nice...

OR ...buy another one ..!

Great thread and great pics Excellent work!

[quote=Flashlight Foy]


I plan to include perhaps individual shots along with different caps shown on a light for comparison.

[/quote]

Please, do include more photos.

Awesome thread & photos!

Really good info for me as I plan to buy several Solarforce products.

i hate your great photos! it makes me want to buy a l2t with s11, clip and ss bezel

i don't need it at all but i want it bad

Very nice, thanks!

Although now that I have read this, I get second thoughts of that S8 that I already ordered since it seems to be HUGE!!

No, I don´t have MP... New L2 will quite certainly look ridiculous with it :D

Well, now I know that I should bought that S9, which I was in the first place...

Excellent. Can you comment a bit on forwrad clickies as which one is the closest to being silent?

Okay, Budget; the forward clickies from loud to less loud:

S10 - feels firm which may account for the increased sound

S8 - a bit softer, requiring a slightly longer push

S11 - a more subdued click, not as sharp

S6 - longer actuation with a smooth click threshold

S9 - a higher pitched sound at odds with its masculine appearance

I didn't mean to make it sound like a wine tasting event but, it's the best I could do.

gofetchmeaswitchFoy

As promised, here's some quick shots with the different caps, each on the latest edition L2P. Hopfully you'll get an idea of relative size . . .

S8 - In addition to not screwing down all the way, it looks pretty dumb. Probably because the tail is bigger than the head.

The same tail cap on a 2 x 18650 equipped Masterpiece Pro looks killer. Still not convinced? Here's another shot:

S11 - Much better. This switch looks great on this new L2P or the 2011 version L2.

S9 - This is Foy's favorite for the L2P. Cap and head appear about the same size and it really feels balanced in the hand.

S6 - I actually like the stock cap better than this. My least favorite.

New design L2P on the left and same L2P on the right with the old design tail cap.

Same L2P, new switch on the left, old on the right.

This is the new L2P with the 2011 version L2's tail cap. Danged if I can tell the difference.

S10 - This one comes with the L2T and it looks as different on the L2P as it does on the new L2.

Here's the S10 (L2T) cap on the new L2. I read somewhere here (maybe old4570?) that said the L2T has the same finish as the new L2. I think it looks and feels different.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

These are some fun shots showing the kind of flashlights that crank Foy's Evinrude. They also illustrate how a front bezel and tail cap can take a torch upmarket.

This new design L2P is sporting a top-of-the-line Foybezel™ creation from the prestigious stainless steel collection.

2011 version L2 with stainless Foybezel™

Perhaps the finest P60 hosts money can buy.

Foy

You beat me to it!

Sticky'd and Frontpage'd. Very well done as usual, Foy! A wealth of tailcap goodness in this post.

Thanks Foy!

Just ordered a S11 and S8.

My wallet thanks you for being lighter.

That S9 is sweet! I see an L2T w/stainless smootth bezel and an S9 switch somewhere in my future.

LOL!

Absolutely lovely. I know nothing more as i did before but it was worth it. :)

It may come as a surprise, but hunters love noiseless switches (forward are preferred). That's why i'm asking.

This is an S4 and i believe it is discontinued. Forward clickie, very aesthetically pleasing and almost completely dead silent. Can't be heard at all from 2-3m away in a very very quiet room at night (less ambient noise).

HowcomeyoudontownoneFoy?