Has Anyone Been Following Carly Rose Sonenclar On X-Factor

I appreciate a good talent when I see one, and this girl Carly Rose is it. At only 13 she has got the best voice I have seen or heard. It’s just amazing. Here’s her first audition for this years X-Factor. Of coure it’s probably all staged beforehand with what the judges say, and how the show is played out, but nonetheless the fact that this girl can sing with anyone can’t be denied, especially at such a young age of 13. She is only going to get better and better.

Sorry Boaz, but he couldn’t begin to do with his voice what Carly can do with hers. And she is only 13. Wait until she gets 18. Like I told you even the great Carrie Underwood would be doing good at this moment to beat her in a sing-off competition. Carrie at 13 would of got chewed up and spit out from Carly. This girl is only going to get way better. It’s unreal how great she is now at 13.

Watch her chew up and spit out Beatrice Miller at the same age as Carly.

I've been watching the Voice. Ungodly talent this season! It's a shame that any one of the remaining 8 have to go home, they all deserve to win. In comparison, watching the X-Factor is like watching amateur hour. That Carly girl is my favorite on that show but the others??? I can't see how they can praise their performances they way they've been. I've lost respect for Simon. He's been wearing kid gloves this season.

In all fairness, Tate Stevens is gonna be a country music star I have no doubt. And the group Emblem 3 is going to have some future big hits no doubt about it in my mind. The X-Factor does have some good talent this year. And Samantha Jade who won the Austrailian X-Factor is going to be a huge sensation soon.

Here she is giving a singing seminar.

Trevin Hunte singing Jenifer Hudson's "And I'm Telling You". He sings it so well that her version pales in comparison.

Well the judges can’t believe how good Carly really is at 13. LA Reid got it right. Carly will be the winner.

Show me any 13 yr old girl that can sing this dang good.

Then there is Amanda Brown's rendition of "Dream on". Oh baby!! :love:

I fully agree with you. For her age she’s amazing. The rest I’ve seen on the show…meh.

If you haven't seen Nicholas David perform you are truly missing out!

He’s pretty dang good.

Wow! A lot of talented singers!

Not an X-Factor contestant, but if we're considering young voices to follow over the years, how about that Jackie Evancho? She's 12, btw.

That girl is good. But she has only one style of voice-opera.

Carly Rose can sing a variety of songs and do them in a way that others can’t. She has more control of her voice than anyone I have seen for her age. And she has a voice that can sing a variety of tones and pitches better than anyone I have seen at 13. She sings already like someone that is 21.

There’s no way she should of finished in 2nd palce after a sensational performance like this. You just can’t top this. And nobody did that nite. But it’s up to the fans and how they vote. Tate was great, but not this great.

Honestly I think the talent on the voice has been much better

I disagree.

Samantha Jade will be 10 times the star than Amanda Brown.