Imalent MS12

KawiBoy1428 · 2018-10-02T01:27:04.000Z

DENGOH:

Flashaholics:

I felt zero air enter or leave the light.

Looks like Imalent successfully design a mini convection oven, in wrong product though :person_facepalming: .

That is why they went with the first Gen 70’s they take longer to COOK…

Jerommel · 2018-10-02T01:39:19.000Z

So they build a light that blinds you with the spill reflecting on the ground, and then they forget to research how you implement a fan…
The bit of airflow outward gets immediately sucked back in by the inlets, apparently…

DENGOH · 2018-10-02T02:00:25.000Z

KawiBoy1428:

DENGOH:

Flashaholics:

I felt zero air enter or leave the light.

Looks like Imalent successfully design a mini convection oven, in wrong product though :person_facepalming: .

That is why they went with the first Gen 70’s they take longer to COOK…

Ya, i think this one can really cook, 80+ degree celcius external temperature can really cook something. Wonder what would be the internal temperature. :question:

DENGOH · 2018-10-02T02:03:03.000Z

Jerommel:

So they build a light that blinds you with the spill reflecting on the ground, and then they forget to research how you implement a fan…
The bit of airflow outward gets immediately sucked back in by the inlets, apparently…

I was thinking this morning could it be the fan spinning too fast compared to prototype. Don’t know why Imalent engineers can accept this kind of active cooling with minimal airflow?

Jerommel · 2018-10-02T02:05:20.000Z

The faster it spins, the more air displacement.
Maybe they forgot an air intake altogether…

mortuus · 2018-10-02T08:02:35.000Z

Flashaholics:

I felt zero air enter or leave the light.

hm where does all those hundreds of watts heat go then? makes no sense…. If hot air just is trapped inside that light will not function well in the long run. That much heat must vent and go out and not stay trapped, its like a furnace in there…

Like i said there is a reason olight and now acebeam ditched the internal fans, i doubt imalent have made anything groundbreaking with that fan? it doesnt sound so atleast too me…

DENGOH · 2018-10-02T08:14:11.000Z

mortuus:

Flashaholics:

I felt zero air enter or leave the light.

hm where does all those hundreds of watts heat go then? makes no sense…. If hot air just is trapped inside that light will not function well in the long run. That much heat must vent and go out and not stay trapped, its like a furnace in there…

Like i said there is a reason olight and now acebeam ditched the internal fans, i doubt imalent have made anything groundbreaking with that fan? it doesnt sound so atleast too me…

Heat can be transferred from one place to another by three methods: conduction in solids, convection of fluids (liquids or gases), and radiation through anything that will allow radiation to pass.

So now it has conduction from mcpcb to light head, and radiation from light head to surrounding, but not much convection due to ineffective fan design.

DENGOH · 2018-10-02T08:18:36.000Z

Basically all non-active cool flashlights don’t have much convection unless user blow an external fan on the flashlights. MS12 supposed to make use of convection to transfer heat away with air.

JasonWW · 2018-10-02T11:32:06.000Z

DENGOH:

So now it has conduction from mcpcb to light head, and radiation from light head to surrounding, but not much convection due to ineffective fan design.

Right, all flashlights use convection (unless they are in a vacuum), but it’s relatively weak. Using a fan is called forced convection. It greatly speeds up or helps the heat transfer.

Even though other MS12 users show air entering one side and exiting the other, it’s not a straight forward flow. The fan style they are using just seems odd. I’ve never seen that style of fan used like this before. The only thing close was the FB1 below.

In fact, here are all the airflow patterns on the active cooled lights I know of.

The prototype Olight X9.

I’m guessing on this Microfire due to lack of data.

The protoype X70. It had 3 fans so it looked like it had 3 dividers using 120° of the diameter. So it had 3 inlets and 3 outlets.

The new version of the X70 has the external fan and “looks” like it has air blowing across the exterior.

I am still guessing on the MS12 design. Their fan style and layout is very odd. I’m guessing they are using a divider to get the air to go in one side and out the other, but it’s not working very well.

Jerommel · 2018-10-02T11:47:46.000Z

JasonWW:

The fan style they are using just seems odd. I’ve never seen that style of fan used like this before.

Used in laptops a lot.
It’s a centrifugal fan. Picks up air in the centre and blows it out the outer perimeter.
It basically spins the air that’s in there and flings it outward.
Very effective.
Vacuum cleaners work that way too.

JasonWW · 2018-10-02T11:50:07.000Z

Jerommel:

JasonWW:

The fan style they are using just seems odd. I’ve never seen that style of fan used like this before.

Used in laptops a lot.
It’s a centrifugal fan. Picks up air in the centre and blows it out the outer perimeter.
It basically spins the air that’s in there and flings it outward.
Very effective.
Vacuum cleaners work that way too.
Unfortunately it doesn’t seem to work very well in the Imalent…

You misunderstood me. I’m familiar with all fan types, but centrifugal is not often seen inside flashlights. The FB1 uses a centrifugal, but it’s orientated differently.

mortuus · 2018-10-02T11:51:47.000Z

Yes the type of fan in the middle of the light makes no sense to me, it doesnt seem like its magical just sucks the cold air from one side and throws out all the hot air on the other side, if it was that easy other light makers would have figured that out long before imalent, it doesnt take a rocket scientist to figure that out.

Would be interesting see the inside of the head if there are air channels or something to get the flow out somehow…

Theodore41 · 2018-10-02T12:35:17.000Z

They have to call a aerodynamics expert to fix the problem.

DENGOH · 2018-10-02T12:44:58.000Z

Imalent should be held responsible if this flashlight burn someone accidentally. To be king of lumen it must also take care of user safety. I can’t imagine those who has less flashlight knowledge paying full price and get themselves a dangerous tool. If buyers think MS12 gets too hot in such a short time and request return for refund, would Imalent accept return? Sport car that can accelerate very fast will also brake to still very fast, it’s safety that is utmost important.

The_Flashaholic · 2018-10-02T12:57:40.000Z

I think Blippi at ASF got 71c for his heat test at the head, kinda in the middle of the 3 tests I did. I’d be interesting to see if that was from a full charge.

Bridgtec commented his fan was quiet which seems odd.

M4D_M4X · 2018-10-02T14:32:03.000Z

did he ever say something negative in his reviews?

I think the Fan design is not perfect

but before I post my conclusion I need to open the light to see if it's fixable or not.

the MS12 and R90C are 100% not toys and should handled with care!

Theodore41 · 2018-10-02T14:38:55.000Z

M4D M4X:

>the MS12 and R90C are 100% not toys and should handled with care!

What do you mean exactly?I ask because I’ll get a R90C.
I pass MS12 because I have the DX80 which is more than enough for me.

JasonWW · 2018-10-02T14:48:50.000Z

Flashaholics:

Blippi at ASF

Are you calling Matt/Vestureofblood Blippi? Where does this name come from?

Jerommel · 2018-10-02T14:48:59.000Z

Not toys ?? :partying_face:
Well, not children’s toys, that’s true.

The_Flashaholic · 2018-10-02T15:22:16.000Z

M4D M4X:

did he ever say something negative in his reviews?

I think the Fan design is not perfect

but before I post my conclusion I need to open the light to see if it’s fixable or not.

the MS12 and R90C are 100% not toys and should handled with care!

He mentioned the MS12 needs a layer of polystyrene over it in the box to stop the lid denting.