LED questions

I’ve been searching around for answers for a couple of questions but I’m getting a headache so I’ll just ask them here and hope someone answers :slight_smile:

I know dedoming LEDs is done for better through and I see people do it on zoom-lights also, but how does dedoming affect the widest beam mode on a zoom-light?
For some lights I see suggestions to use either XM-L2 or XP-G2. I am familiar with XM-L2, but what is the difference with XP-G2? Why would someone choose XP-G2 over XM-L2?

De-domed zoomies just get less output (lower lumens) in flood mode - maybe 15-20%, plus of course the tint shift you get from de-doming will show as well, but aspherics also can effect tint of the beam.

Dedoming reduces lumens by approximately 20% in most lights, but in the zoomie lights it doesn't seem to affect the widest beam mode too much and the beam width is the same.

The XP-G2 has a higher surface brightness (intensity) than the XM-L2 at a given drive current. That higher surface brightness can lead to better throw, especially in a zoomie. You do give up lumens though and the die image is smaller than the XM-L2. I prefer a dedomed XM-L2 in reflector lights and I haven't yet tried one in the UF-T20, which I used a dedomed XP-G2 in. I figured that I would get more throw with less current in that light.

Another advantage I'm seeing with the dedomed XP-G2 is that the color/tint shift appears to be much less than what I get with an XM-L2. I even dedomed (accidentally ) a 3C XP-G2 and it still looks great.

If I understand correctly, dedoming and using XP-G2 is only advisable if I want more throw out of the light?

I would have no reason to dedome the LED if my main interest with a zoomie is the mid to widest range beam? And I would be better off using XM-L2?

If you want to mostly use the wide end of the zoom then yes I would stick with the XM-L2. It puts out a lot more lumens at 3A than the XP-G2 and will give you a brighter flood.

The domed XP-G2 should give you more throw than the domed XM-L2.