As I get curiouser and curiouser, I have found there to be no real rhyme or reason for the lens o-ring. Is there one proper placement, and many of my lights just had poor quality control.
Usually if the light wasn't designed to use the oring between lens & reflector, it won't seal around the outside against the ID of the head. Lights like the SRK are built to do it that way, also the Convoy S4 which has a groove in the front face of the reflector for the oring. 501b & Maglites have the oring groove in the bezel.