I have lights that are the maximum of each while sacrificing the other (most cases) and then everything in between.
Everyone will likely answer the same: what is your intended use for the light?
I frequently go night hiking and aside from my crazy headlamp I don’t need more flood which is why I’m on a thrower binge.
I also do renos and electrical work on my house which means my floody lumen crazy lights are perfect for a ceiling bounce portable worklight