The 10 degree beaded optic is like 10% or less loss in lux with no visible rings anywhere. hot spot fades into corona which fades into spill.

The 5 degree smooth has basically the same hot spot (it’s not more throwy) as stock but changes the corona up a little, maybe slighly less rings but it’s still not smooth by TIR standards.

The 15 degree smooth turns it into a bat signal (10-15% loss in lux) but the hotspot is very wide, smooth and round with corona and spill fading to nothing quickly. (reminds me of my Carclo smooth narrow triples with LH351D)



I think I like 10 degree beaded the best of the ones I tried followed by 15 degree smooth.