I won’t have any other button top 18650s until I receive my LT1. But your’re probably right that it’s unlikely the problem has anything to do with the batteries. They supply enough current to power all 9 LEDs in High mode, and I usually just use one side (3 LEDs) in Low or Medium. I’ll put them through a discharge test anyway.
I also plugged an electronic load into the USB socket, and the current coming out of it isn’t enough to power the display.