P60 pill with raised center - big problem?

Hey there,

I received two empty P60 dropins today that seem to have a major flaw IMO. The pill where the emitter sits is not completely flat, it has a raised center. If you put an LED on a star in there, it will basically just float on the center and wobble around if you press down on the sides.

My first thought was "not good", but since I didn't build too many dropins until now, I thought I'd ask you if this sort of thing sometimes just happens and perhaps it's not as big a deal as I think it is. I already opened a ticket with Fasttech to see what they think of it.

Picture (click to enlarge):

i’ve only started to build my own p60s, but i’d say no good… the star needs to sit flat in order to transfer heat…

i just ordered a pill (c8) from them as well… fingers crossed… would be a pain to flatten without the use of something like a lathe…

1 Thank

Yeah, I thought so too. I already started thinking about how I could flatten the thing, but it would be a pain since I would have to grind it flat with a dremel and then polish it again.

How does it look inside?
If it’s the opposite maybe you can smack it with a hammer to flatten it.
I think fasttech probably will replace them though.

They are all like that. So fix it. C-clamp or vise grips, set something small on the LED-side, and something bigger than the OD on the bottom, and push it down until it's flat. Do a little at a time and recheck with the MCPCB to see if it still high centers.

OK thanks, I'll try that as soon as I heard back from FT.

But they're not all like that. The one pictured is SKU 1208509, the one with the XP-E reflector. I also have one of their XM-L dropins and it is way better.

Let me put it another way: So many of them are that way, you can just safely assume they all will be, and be prepared to do the 'band them flat' trick as a matter of routine.

Yeah, not all, but a lot are like it. I try to use ones with the slightly raised centre in my lower current drop-ins.

Alright, so with P60 dropins I basically have to assume the worst and with a little luck I might encounter an occasional nice surprise :smile:

I was not aware of this issue and plan to build my first P60 drop-in soon. Thanks for the tips!
-Garry

But why? The centers are very thin, just make them flat and they'll be exactly the same as the ones that don't need bending. No need to set them aside or anything. Making them flat is just as much a part of building p60s as is gluing the MCPCB into place or soldering the wires. Just one of those things you have to do.

I guess I never considered it. To me they don’t seem that thin, it’s not like the centre is bent inwards, but more that there is more material in the middle. I’ll think about some things I can use flatten it next time.

here's another solution.

as long as the pill surface is smooth, i put a oversized donut shaped material like a nut or washer, and clamp it over the LED while the paste, epoxy is curing or solder being heated. This way the MCpCB conforms to the surface of the pill. obviously you would try your best to make the pill as flat as possible.

OK, I was able to fix it like this. Kudos to comfychair

I put a disc made out af a guitar pick between the pill and the screw to protect the surface.

Thanks comfychair and Steve_the_Chief for the idea.

Just about 2 out of every 3 pills I receive are slightly convex, and I had been sanding them down with fine grit paper and a dowel - very time consuming. I didn’t think of pressing them flat until I saw this thread. I used a 2” C-clamp which has a 16mm diameter screw plate, and it worked! No more sanding!

Thanks again guys.


Edit - After trying the pressing method on a few more pills, it’s looking like results can vary from pill to pill. Some are coming out close to perfect, others are showing very little change. My setup is pretty crude and could be to blame, or it could be an indication of just how inconsistent these pills are.

Nice!

Sometimes as the facing tool gets dull the center of the cut pushes away from the tool. This means less material is being removed from the center than from the edge. When it is thin like this the center will return to it’s normal or relaxed state when the tool moves away. Machinist call this “push off”.

How bowed are we talking about here? In the PC world a convex surface is often considered a desirable property for a CPU heatsink base. The convex base ensures that the most pressure is applied directly above the heat source. I’ve definitely seen concern on the forums that screwing a star down to a flat heatsink would result in the star bowing outwards and trapping a too-thick layer of TIM between the star and it’s mating surface.

Some are just slightly bowed, while others are almost conical with a pointed tip. I don’t think they do it intentionally.

A convex surface might be desirable where you have a lot of pressure holding the parts together, but I don’t think flashlight parts use enough pressure for it to be desirable.

Good point about less pressure.