same led, different tint?

I just put together a convoy m1 with a qlite driver and an XML-2 t6 3c … everything is the same as my s2 from 1yr ago, but this appears to be at a higher color temp—-similar to my fenix pd30 Q5. I’m not complaining as this led and the m1 is super nice btw get one if you done have one. just wonder if the 1 yr old led in my s2 has changed color over time or is it the different reflector? my s2 looks warm compared to the m1 build. thoughts?

I don’t think it would get warmer with age. The bins have some width, they might just be on opposite sides of the same color bin. Or maybe one is not quite as described. Do the lenses look the same?

the domes looks the same but the two reflectors are quite different.

A reflector shouldn’t change the light color normally, unless there is something special about your reflector?

I’d say its hard to say exactly what the issue is, but easy to see it happening. You don’t appear to know the bin and tint of the light you had starting, it could have been warmer than you realized, with no known tint to compare to, you’d probably not realize at all: my 4C appears yellowish vs cold white lights, but take it out alone and it is just white after a while. I just turned on my incandescent mag light again recently and was surprised how warm it was.

If you compare two LEDs in the same bin but at the extreme edges of a bin against each other, you may think you have one of each of the warmer and the cooler bins surrounding it. Also, if you have two LEDs next to each other in bin, take the warmer bin and get one of the most extreme corner of cold shift on the chart within that bin, and the cooler bin and choose one of the most extreme corner of warm shift within that bin and its possible you may perceive a reversal of expected tint comparing the two, where the warmer looks cooler than the cool bin.

Next, 3Cs appear to be more notoriously varied in their tint than others it seems, I’ve had one pretty green, one nice white, some report them being yellowish…not many samples but more variability than I’ve seen in any other tint and others complain of this too. For a while there was even talk of whether 3C U2 even existed, and that maybe some were just substituting other LEDs and calling them 3C U2

thanks for the info. I pulled the packing slip from the 1yr old led and it was a also a t6 3c. and like stated above, it has a much warmer tint with a hint of the yellow-green people have mentioned