Soldering MCPCB to Heatsink/Pill - Advice needed

I see a lot of folks here are soldering their copper MCPCBs directly to the heatsink/pill.

I often make a copper sink mainly as a spacer and fasten the Noctigon to it and it to the pill with AA. I’d like to start soldering them together but there’s one thing that has me puzzled.

I know aluminum components are out but lets assume copper MCPCB to copper sink to brass pill.

What do I solder first, flow the emitter to the PCB, then PCB to the sink and last sink to pill? Some other order or maybe try to do it all at once?

Do I use a hotplate or my soldering station?

It seems to me no matter what I do everything is going to reach the same temp at roughly the same time and I’ll have to align all the parts at the same time. Maybe using solder with different melting temps but that sounds complicated.

While I’m at it I assume most use solder paste for this, any recommendations on brand?
I’ve tried soldering a few copper rounds to make a sink but results have been poor at best, I think it’s do to the past I purchased. It just doesn’t seem to melt no matter how much head I use. (Superior Solder Pastes No 3033-85 No-Clean SN96.5/Ag 3.5)

Sorry if I’m asking an obvious question but I didn’t find a thread with any details.

read that most don’t do the solder to make upgrades and alignment easier. I do sometimes put two small beads between pill and driver while other use wire to lock in place. I use AS5 between pill and star and never had a light go nova at 5 amp and below range.

The pros from Dover should be chiming in on solder pros and cons and such.

GL

Lead free solder has a much higher melting temp. I don't think anybody here uses it because of that.

I do LED-MCPCB-pill all in one go.

I o this also with the same solder paste at both junctions.

I would also like to know, Can someone post instructions or even better, a video?

Thanks!

I do all in one go as well, although I have not attempted a ‘quadripple’ as you described.

I heat from the bottom with a butane torch, with everything pre-stacked & pasted, which works fine for the small-medium pills. Larger/thicker copper ’sinks may need some additional heat applied directly to them.

I'm more into drilling/taping a couple of screws. Don't like the permanence of soldering, and the screws seem to make a great bond with using a high qual thermal grease.

Tom, I'd like you to do a quick test next time you put one together. Paint the bottom of the star with Sharpie, then screw it down like normal but without any paste, then pull it and see where the ink has transferred to the pill top.

This is my favorite way. I add the emitter at the end and move the pill on to something cool like a chunk of aluminum.

I’ve done it both ways, soldering the star to the pill first and soldering the led to the star first. I use whichever method lessens the risk to the led for that mod. Sometimes I need the pill/star combo assembled quite a ways before i need the led and dont want to risk damaging the led during the fitting process.

I think you are trying to say the pill tops ain't so flat - yes, I check for that. For P60's (and other brass ones), I do the flattening technique, and I always do the sanding to 2500 GRIT. No guarantees I'm getting them perfectly flat, but my results seem to indicate improvements (holds output better in the lightbox). Of course the screw down method works great on aluminum pills, which is the majority, for me at least.

Of course another way, besides the sharpie, is to see how much thermal grease squeezes out compared to how much was applied. I do find quite often not so flat surfaces, but again, this is mostly aluminum. I also check with a flat edge, whether it's an inny or outy pill top - this is what I do to confirm the flattening of the P60's as well. For zoomies with an aluminum pill, the best choice seems to be the screws. I wish I had your setup and skills to cut out pill tops and replace with copper - I've done a couple of press fit copper mods but only with hollow pill lights - mostly cheaper zoomies, and takes me hours, unfortunately.

I really need a jig/fixture like you have to turn parts under the drill press - no idea where to even begin buying or building something like that. I have the drill press but can't use it much because lacking a decent fixture.

Nope, nothing to do with the parts not being flat when you start. Try it, I think you'll be really unimpressed with how much contact area there is.

You mean after my usual prep work of sanding?

about silver solder? Just between copper star and pill? Then lower temp 60/40 between the die and star?

Someone tested paste vs. 60/40 but curious about real world difference between the three.

Keeping the LED centered would be the challenge for new guys like myself…

I've been told to keep solder paste in the refrig, and even still, it has a limited shelf life, like 6 months. Once it drys out, it's done. I had problems with it melting when it got old, dry. Are you storing it in the refrig? How old?

One jar of the cheap paste I use has partially dried out (just starts to get thick/hard to spread evenly) several times and a little squirt of Kester liquid flux brings it right back to life.

------

Tom, prep everything just like normal, just use Sharpie instead of the thermal paste and check the pattern. I would tell you what you're going to find, but I don't want to spoil it.

It will have to be next time - I don't know when. Maybe by this weekend? Not sure....

Illuminaria wrote:

about silver solder? Just between copper star and pill? Then lower temp 60/40 between the die and star?

I like the way you think. That's exactly what I do, but mostly because I don't like the way lead-free electical solder flows (or should I say doesn't flow). This silver bearing is used by some for HVAC work and it flows quite nicely. Its flux is not compatible with electronics. So it's important to clean up well after using. Probably expensive. I bought it along time ago for an HVAC type project. Really strong too.

in laptops you can have a small CPU i7 dye that needs to dissipate 45 to 55 watts. The method is to use your choice of several TIM for that purpose.

Silver, diamond and liquid metal compounds are some top choices with, lol, peanut butter and toothpaste thrown in to aggravate the purist. The purpose of the TIM is to fill in the micro air gaps that cannot be fully removed by lapping.

The soldering of the led-star-pill is certainly an art to pull it off with LED centered and all. I like to solder as I do it at my job but see the pros and cons of both methods; so it’s looking like each to his/her own.

Interesting to see how folks are soldering their pills. I’ll pick up some better paste and give it a try and yes, the paste I have has been stored in the fridge. It may be old though, very thick and grainy.

I’ve been using A/S thermal paste and A/A epoxy where needed in lights up to around 7 amps and all have held up well. It’s just that darn voice in the back of my head telling me there might be something better.

Thanks,