Soupcan Lights Durability Question

Looking at them I have wondered about the SRK and some other soupcan lights due to the quite thin plated contact area for the batteries on the driver boards in the head. The plated contact seems to exist in the SRK and all clones I have seen as well as in the Solarstorm SP03, T3 and T4 as well as the Warrior and the Small Sun ZY-T08. The way the battery tubes hold the batteries they rub against the driver board contact area every time the batteries are removed for recharging or replacement.

Lights with much thicker contact rings include the SupFire M6 and L1, the Black Shadow Terminators and Darth as well as the Nitecore Tiny Monster lights and the Roche M170.

Has any one actually had a light with the thin battery contact surface damaged or destroyed due to the thinness of this contact area? I have seen posts expressing concern but have not actually seen reports of damage or failures so is the concern only theoretical?

You could run a bead of soldier around that ring, as per ComfyChair.

Several toughening solutions I can think of but my question is basically is there something to worry about or not?

No point in adding additional material if the design is not actually causing a problem for anyone. Do you have a link to photos of the ComfyChair solution as adding solder around the ring does not sound to me like a solution that would actually solve the battery positive contact problem, if there is one? Soldering a copper or brass washer on would do so but that does not seem like what you described.

I looked for a pic, but couldn’t find it. If I remember right it wasn’t in one of his own threads but as his comment to someone else’s.
I am concerned about mine and keep an eye on them. When the need arises, I know what I have to do.

Or, skip the copper and just use solder. If after a few years the solder wears down just add more.

Comfychair;

Was that done as a repair or just as insurance so to speak? My basic question is trying to determine if there is a genuine durability concern with the thin PCB copper plating battery contacts or not.

I had well over 500 complete discharge cycles on my original SRK. The cheap thin battery tube threads completely wore out before the + contact surface on the driver. I always kept the contact plate and threads lubed with dielectric grease (silicon lube).

Its now FP modded and sits on a fixed mount on my bicycle, supplied by a removable 18 x 18650 remote pack under the seat. Not bad for a bike light. :bigsmile:

Lube your contact plate on these type of lights and they should never wear out (assuming you dont have any sharp burs on top of your + cell contact surfaces. If you do, sand them off and make them smooth.

Thanks FlashPilot, that’s good info.

Richwouldnt, I haven’t got much useful to add. The main thing I can think of that the nicer (M6 style) contact ring might help with is batteries from pack pulls. If something isn’t done to the tops they often have rough spots. OTOH I don’t know that even that would cause a problem. It’s just what springs to mind. Sorry I don’t have anything constructive to add.

I've wondered about this before. It might be a good excuse for me to buy a metal punch kit to make some "washers" that will fit the driver. Even though it may not be the first point of failure, it's one of those mods that make me feel better.

I use a drop of Superlube on the contact plate. It's subjective but it seemed to close quieter and smoother afterward applying it.