I just started using my NiteCore UM4.

I put 4 batteries into it, and they are charging right now.

The charger says the "Charging Status" of two of the batteries is "Poor."

The "poor" batteries are brand new Molicel INR-21700-P42A from liionwholesale.com

https://liionwholesale.com/collections/batteries/products/molicel-npe-inr-21700-p42a-45a-4200mah-flat-top-21700-battery-authorized-distributor

Here is what it says in the manual about Charging Status:

My question is...

Why would brand new cells from a reputable source need to be replaced?