I haven’t tried resistor mods but I went through similar emitter deliberations with my Catapult V6 and have gone from the original XHP35 Hi to XHP50 and finally back to XHP35 but HD.

I too found the original V6’s XHP35 Hi beam a little too pencilly for my needs. So I modded in an XHP50.2 4000K. The hotspot was less intense but much larger and more useful for my needs (mentioned in MOD TODAY post)

I subsequently modded an unsed Manker U21 (which also originally came XHP35 Hi) with a sliced XHP50.2 4000K 90-CRI which I liked even more than the V6 with XHP50.2. Since the U21 replaced the V6’s duties, rather than have the V6 go unused I decided to somewhat try the Catapult V6 with an XHP35 HD at 4000K as a compromise. The hotspot is larger than the original XHP35 Hi while still fairly throwy (I don’t have metered measurements.)

Ether the XHP35 HD or XHP50.2 (sliced) will result in a slightly larger hotspot. In my case I prefered the XHP50,2 sliced primarily because it’s Hi-CRI. Between the Catapult V6’s original XHP35 Hi and the XHP35 HD, for my needs I prefer the HD. In either case you’d be giving up some distance for a larger hotspot.


Bear in mind that these are from two different lights/reflectors but at only 10ft from the wall, when the camera’s exposure is reduced you can begin to see that the sliced XHP50.2 (on left) has a tighted hotspot than the XHP35 HD (on right). At greater distances the difference is probably 2x in diameter.

I haven’t tried the newest XHP35.2 yet so I don’t know how it compares to the XHP35.

Hope this helps. Looking forward to hearing about your results.