I have two D4s, a D1, and a D1S. My friend also has a D4.

I do not abuse them but I’ve been very happy with all of them. I use the D4s most, and have had a few drops onto hard surfaces without any failures. Just some scratches and scrapes.

The anodizing wears quite easily on my smooth black D4, but this is just cosmetic. It has a few bare spots from rubbing against my jeans while clipped to my pocket.

A broken lens is simple to replace by unscrewing the front bezel. If you break the glass lens, perhaps you could replace it with a more durable polycarbonate lens.