I had problems similar to yours as well as the lights flickering when I got my 3 SF-01s. However when I went through the programming modes they became rough solid, except for 1 flaky tailcap. Try going through the programming modes and see if that helps.

And all 3 lights were dimmer with a new cr123 than an AA Eneloop for some reason.

The difference between high and low really isn’t noticeable unless one is paying close attention. Maybe yours came programmed as high only?