I was asked to post a poll, given these two choices, for the anodizing finish of the two new HaikeLite models being worked on. Threads can be found here:
Unfortunately there's only these two choices at this time, understanding that clear or silver/metal color anodized finishes have gotten popular here as of late.
Ahhh, good question. Think so, I'd say they are both in the flat (carbon) black category but I'm so expert on finishes. Generally the flat black finished are gripier but tend to show finger prints (oils, stains) easier.
As will34 pointed out, there's differences of flat black (and shiny/gloss) finishes out there, while they may be all of equal quality (hardening, penetration depth, etc.). I'm sure it depends a lot on the exact process and ingredients, including the exact aluminum alloy.
Yes - I have the Z1, X1, and even the Cometas, plus a Convoy L2 and L6, all I'd consider some level of "flat" black. I could be wrong, but the HA III term is often mis-used. Actually it's technically incorrect - there's Type II and Type III, where Type III is considered "Hard Anodized".
For some good reference reading on anodizing, try:
Without having seen either, I’d definitely like to see the carbon flat black version. Can’t wait to see your review Tom, and hope Haikelite is going to give us more details and pictures
Yes, It’s ture. Carbon black finish show finger prints easy and you have to clean it. The grip feel is super nice and it’s not too hard to make it clean.
Will show some pictures for HaikeLite with Carbon black anodizing tomorrow.
HAIII classic black is nice too, Grip feel is not that good. The prototypes you saw in the OP’s pictures was made by HAIII Classic black finish.
Oh man, the flat blacks are an issue with a lot/large smooth surfaces, but the Z1, X1, L2, L6 lights have a good amount of knurling, fins, and other features with not many open flat surfaces. I think the new HaikeLites are similar, with not much flat surfacing.
Well dunno - it certainly helps breaking up the surfaces, but I'm sure things still do show.
I've been told the sample/proto sent (or to be sent) for the XHP70 thrower is in the flat black finish, so I'll be able to a get a good impression how it marks up, uhhh, holds up