Depends. Some just need an insulator (paper, PETE, etc.) and you just lay the reflector over the LED for the right spacing. Other times, you actually need a spacer to have the reflector sit a fixed distance off the LED. Yet other times, you’d need an adapter ring to convert from one size to another (eg, to use an XP-sized LED in a reflector made for an XM).
I got an F13 that has an actual spacer. Focus is okay, but a little fuzzy and a bit ringy. So I punch out the spacer and use an insulator instead, to let the LED sit a bit deeper in the reflector. Ecch! About the same focus, but horrible colors: a lemon-yellow hotspot and corona, and a horrid Angry Blue™ spill. Backing it out with the spacer again let those colors “blend” better.
Point being, sometimes you just have to try a few ways and see what works best.
If the hole’s definitely too big for the LED, ie, there’s “wiggle room” around it, then you definitely need a centering ring. That’s the only “must”. Other than that, it’s just experimenting.
Pretty sure I can machine something up on my lathe. All the reflectors I have are these. I just bought a bunch of them to try and it said on the Ledil website XHP70.
So in some instances then they could be just sat above the sinkpad barely touching it? Just a question of focus as you said.
Should be able to. Worst case, wedge a few fat o-rings between the reflector and LED to test the focus as you loosen/tighten the bezel to squish down on them (ie, the o-rings act like springs pushing back).