Only if you feed it twice a day with the highest grade of wagyu beef steak.
Haha jks. In an ideal world, yes it is very capable of that figure.
So if the current regulating chips were perfect, you had perfect heat sinking, no lens loss, etc...
OTF lumens would probably be anywhere from 650-750.
I'm going to +1 the S5 because I was really suprised at how nice a cheap EDC can be.
And being significantly cheaper than an EagleTac or Crelant or similar, you don't really have to treat it as a prized possession.
If you really are serious about getting into flashlights, there really is no escaping lithium for the near future.
Get some decent, non _____Fire 18650's, a reliable charger and you're guaranteed to use them in time to come.
If you're smart about it, you can get the S5, batts and charger for easily less than 50.
(The S5 fits only unprotected batteries well. Most protected batteries are too long. This should be fine with a single battery light with low voltage protection like the S5, anyway. Just keep that in mind when you use it for other lights.)
Welcome to BLF! Don't forget to use the coupon on appropriate sites.