Plain box OK with me. How about increasing the size of the aluminum holder a bit so Ni-MH will work. I would be happy to spend a couple more dollars so this can happen.
I guess just some thicker nimh don’t fit, I had this problem with other devices. Never had fitting issues with white eneloops.
Have you tested eneloops?
What is a plain box? How does the 3AA holder look like?
In what way does the 4XAA carrier not support NiMH? How does it not fit?
If changing the box and including the 3XAA carrier is going to increase shipping costs, I’d say don’t do it. I’d rather spend a little more on a 4XAA battery carrier that works than to spend more on shipping. If you can add the 3XAA carrier without increasing anyone’s cost (including yours and/or Lumintop’s), I’d be in for that. Plain box is okay for me if you end up needing to ship the 3XAA carriers.
Thanks, that is exactly what I thought. In fact, Engineering Toolbox says that three 14mm circles are all that will fit in a 32mm circle. So, I’m not surprised that four 14500’s will not fit into a tube made to hold a single 32650.
I have plastic 3AA battery holders just like in the photo. I would not need extensive modifications of the SD10 like boring a larger diameter of the flashlight tube to be happy. I say, once the driver has new code the light should be ready to go. I would have no complaints if the light can only 3 AA size batteries. It still is a great flashlight at a good price.
Not looking to argue about the flashlight with anyone. What are the most important qualities of the flashlight for other people?
Oh dear lord they haven’t shipped yet. :zipper_mouth_face:
I’m guessing the rechargeable incompatibility comes from a length issue. The carrier looks like it screws together, its not hard for the end user to increase the length of the carrier. Just ship the darn lights already!
I am still confused about status quo.
So normal AAs fit but nimh not? Is that correct?
If normal AAs fit, eneloops should fit too…I am confused…
DavidEF could you please share where you found that calculation with the circles
Edit: found it myself
So it has to be around 35mm to fit 4AAs
2.41421*smallercircle=biggercircle
2,41421×14=33,79894
2,41421×14,2=34,281782
So are we talking about 0.5mm?
You can choose if you want the 3*AA or the 4*AA holder - but you can’t have both.
So everyone would get the original box (important for me) and there is no trouble about the size of the package.
I will use my one with a 26650 and the two others are going to be used with standard AA batteries, so for me the carrier with 4 slots would be better (it also looks good)