Convoy S2+ from Mountain Electronics

I have never measured it but from here the xpl hi is smaller, not by much though.LED Package/ Die Sizes - WIP -
In pratical purpose about the same as you said. Without the dome though the xpl hi will win the throw contest.

If your looking for flood the xm-l2 is the better choice.
If your going to build your own S2+ and your looking for flood, the xhp50.2 3v might be a better choice. They’re pretty floody in a S2+ reflector.