There are more promising emitters (Lumileds has had a few interesting ones, and LedEngin), but they have weird footsprints and we are sort of stuck with emitters that fit a XM or XP foorprint because that is what we have DTP-MCPCB’s for. XB-D DTP-boards can not be sourced and you need DTP to get the performance you are looking for.
Nowadays it is a bit easier because many companies make DTP-boards and they can be tailor-made in quite small quantities (500 or so), but still someone needs to invest $500 to do that and hope to earn it back somehow.
XB-H = 2.29x2.29mm, XP-G2 = 3.5x3.5, that is quite a difference. The XB-H will even not touch the electrical pads on a XP-board. That said, you could get away with a XP-board if you can get solder to bridge that gap. I should be able to get that done, but it is not a common thing to do.
The XD16 hasn’t a thermal pad (look datasheet 27), and the thermal resistance is not very low at 6 °C/W. In case of using DTP boards (which would be necessary at such high power ratings) it is very hard to electrically insulate anode / cathode from each other.
To be honest, I don’t see that this emitter could be the ‘new old XP-G2’ which everyone is looking for…
And… - this LED is very, very small (1.6 x 1.6 mm) so the handling in reflow is extremely difficult.
The light flux with approx. 450 lumens is much lower than of the XP-G2 / Black Flat, even at maximum over current possible.
Sorry Enderman but I would not change my old XP-G2 S4 2B for your new Osram black flat under any circumstances but that is maybe only because I am building flashlights and not bazookas :laughing:
I have been testing Oslon black flat the last days .
It need quite some work with focusing , since it is a little shorter than your normal Cree leds , but it is really promising . For now i have been testing it on DTP boards only (in lights that doesn’t share the ground on the head of the flashlight , like UT02) , and i’m waiting for MosX boards too .
Results are very good and the led looks very promising … With UT02 which i was getting about 320kcd with dedomed xp-g2 , i’m now seeing 365kcd and i’m still working on getting a better focus