1. Not as far as I am aware. Capacity is good at a bit over the claimed 5000ma & IR is low & the 2 cells are well matched to each other. All things you don”t find with dodgy “fire” brands.
2. Thorfire claim they are made by themselves in their own factory, according to their advert & an email they sent me (but who knows really what goes on in China & they might just be another makers cell, possibly BAK, wrapped in Thorfire wrappers)
3. Liitokala Engineer Lii-500
4. Just that capacity & IR wise they compared very well to my Keeppower, Basen & Liitokala 26650”s & run an S70 fine with no sign of getting hot when run on Turbo (about 5A) continually for around 20 minutes.
eebowler: Thanks for the links. Yes , the 5000mAh is protected.—-While looking on the xtar eBay link at the 4000mAh
in the Battery Specification chart , it states that , Yes it has Protection , but in the eBay ad picture of the 4000mAh it
shows “No Protection Circuit” printed on the battery label.
got 4 of these in today, all measure between 69.1 to 69.3mm. will get capacity check in opus when time permts. made offer of $18 shipped for 4, can’t beat the price.
I’d guess that xtar on ebay is just one, busy, non-native, english speaker. They had a dive light for $46. I asked if it was just the flashlight or the kit since the kits were $91 ish. They basically said Oops, and increased the price. Damit! lol. Also, it doesn’t make sense to me that the 4300mAh cells, WITH protection, are cheaper than the unprotected 4000mAh cells however, I’ll keep my mouth shut this time
bigmike, I’m not US based so these cells may reach me in the next month. I can’t help with specifics even if I wanted to.
Normally you are correct about *fire batteries, but if you get real TrustFire batteries they are good,they are both protected and have the capacity or more that they promise. But of course, not always easy to get real/not faked batteries. I have been lucky from several sellers both on Ebay and other places.
WindyFire has several good tests from HJK, so nobody can claim they do not deliver. But I can’t seem to find any protected 26650 cells there just now. Can be me, or they are out/never had them.
I have several types of Windyfire batteries and they are all good. (Like HKJ says)
SHAME ON YOU XTAR! EDIT: GREAT POLICY XTAR! xtarshop on ebay fully refunded the money, including shipping. I received the 4000mAh cells yesterday. One had an open circuit voltage of 1.06V and the other 0.4V. Do not buy these cells. I’d assume that all cells on sale are in the same condition. Will report to you when the ‘4300mAh’ cells come in.
.
The 1.06V cell would not charge in the Xtar wp2h charger but, started charging in a nitecore i4 only because the i4 is a NiMH charger as well. The 0.4V cell is not charging in anything.