The ones with the white holders fit right on top of the LED. The holders have a little square cutout on the bottom that fits perfectly around the emitter. The holder centers the LED for you and maintains the correct focal length. You need a little epoxy to keep it attached, but that's it.
The ones without the holders need a holder of some kind to center the optic and maintain the optimum focal length.
Most of these optics are 20 to 22mm wide and can't be used with a stock P60 pill and reflector assembly. It won't work even if you bore out the reflector.* You need to either make a custom pill for it like the one made by Vinz or use a stock pill with a custom milled outer ring like Nailbender does for his XRE/optic drop-ins.
*16mm diam or smaller optics will work with a stock P60 pill and reflector if you bore the reflector.
So, in the case of the the P60, if I unscrew the reflector, attach the optic via adhesive, and then counterspring the optic against the head of the torch, it wouldn't work?
I'm having a hard time picturing your description. Where and how would the copper toroid fit?
The basic idea of using the pill without the reflector will work if you can find a way to get adequate surface contact between the pill and the host. But if that involves milling a custom copper adapter to bridge the space between the pill and the host, then I would think that you might as well go all the way and mill a custom copper pill.
That setup will turn on and it will run, but it will have heat problems if you drive it at any harder than 400-500mA. The beam edges will be cutoff also.
You need a way to transfer heat from the pill to the body. And you also need a way to move the pill closer to the host's lens.
Oh wow, you actually desoldered the LED PCB, mounted it on top of a copper heatsink then soldered it back on. Think I'm a bit lazy to do all that, haha.
Great work though!
The Word drawing only took me 10 mins. Too much time spent writing up labs for uni.