Does anyone ( @jon_slider ?) have Opple reading of Nichia 519a 4500k’s Duv (before dedoming)? All my other Nichia LEDs’ numbers are fairly consistent with known specs, except the 519a is unexpectedly giving a negative Duv even with several rounds of testing. That surprises me as numbers from Simon/Convoy indicate it “should” be positive.
OTOH looking at the color of the chart below, it does seem consistently accurate to what I see. More yellowish than magenta’ish and hugging BBL closely.
You left out some info which generally effects measurement of LEDs quite a bit: tir optic/reflector/bare led? what current are you measuring the LED at?
Without that info your measurements are close enough to my own (also from Convoy) to be believed.
Thanks - good points. I tested with Sofirn clear optic but didn’t think about bare LED. Now that I know what’s involved, will be more complete next time.
519a 4500k in Convoy S21D with Sofirn Clear Optic (the OEM frosted optic’s numbers didn’t change much). Tested at center of beam. 100% Brightness: Duv –0.0037 20% Brightness: Duv –0.0019. Other runs ranging –0.0020-0.0030
CCT similar to yours ~ 4100K
I have the old colormunki photo from this link. I got mine used from ebay. AFAIK it’s the cheapest way to get a real spectrophotometer. However once you see the cri and spectrum of a specific CCT of LED the opple seems to give you a ballpark of everything else that varies more.
far superior to Opple as colormunki has full CRI data, including CRI R9 and R12, and is more accurate overall.
but afaik, colormunki requires pairing with a computer and special software… Probably good for people that use PCs and command line interface… I dont know if it runs on a Mac…
Looks like Opple is having significant difficulties in manufacturing these units now. I’m still not a fan of these and think it’s a little disappointing how they have been embraced so much lately in published reviews, etc. without good (more accurate) references with equipment that doesn’t have the same shortcomings, and/or clear disclaimers in the reviews about the source of the graphics/data and the inherent potential for errors therein.
But……did notice this statement on their aliexpress listing. Seems they are considering a Gen 4 unit and are asking for input. The little stock they (maybe) have available in Gen 2/Gen 3 Pro are at decent prices on the site.
thanks for the details, an Android spectrometer for $258.
My wallet is safe, colormunki and ArgylII do not work on my Apple Computer, nor my iPhone
I really appreciate your data shared…
Im also really happy with my Opple, I would buy it again.
They are in stock on Aliex, recommended.
The Opple is suprisingly accurate for CCT, and CRI Ra. If I pick up a light and do not know what LED is in it, my Opple can help me figure out whether it is high cri or low cri, and whether it is 3000K or 4000K, etc…
I find the Opple Tint DUV data Very useful, especially for comparing lights to each other and sharing that info in a beam color photo.
An example of how the Opple can be used to help share tint information and answer questions such as:
Is a Dedomed 5700K 519a as “Pink” as sw45K?
Does the XP-L Hi 5000K have tint duv above or below the bbl, how does it compare in tint to sw45k and DD5700K?
,
(not my photo, not my opple, pic links to source)