If the reflectors so much different, they can not be good focussed for each reflector.
For my GT, I think its not well focussed, the beam is getting thicker and thicker.
I compared my GT with my Astrolux MF02 and it seems that the GT is not realy brighter than the MF02, but the hotspot is smaller than the MF02 (which is not good focussed too). But you have to remember, that I have a faulty LED: BLF GT official support thread [FAQ updated 11 Jan 2018] - #145 by Wieselflinkpro
You could try adding a couple pieces of paper under the black centering thing. See if that makes it better or worse. (this moves the reflector away from the emitter)
If better, add a couple more pieces of paper.
If worse, then you might have to sand down the bottom of the black piece to make it a tiny bit thinner. (this moves the reflector closer to the emitter)
Its less in reall life i guess, the photo makes one spot brighter.
What i also tried is put them on moon light mode and walk towards the wall i will see a square(the led) with mine GT, the other GT there is never really a square it always kinda stays a cirlcle. Maybe other people can try this and tell what they see(or picture)
It’s btw in no way any criticism. Both light throw extremly well. Just slight difference in beam profile, but with so much variables its expected that there are some.
I’m going to measure throw of my GT and Nicolaas’ GT somewhere next week, it seems that you and/or your dad are also in or near Amsterdam?, we could make it a 4x GT session then if you are interested.
I would be very intrerested to find out what exactly is causing the difference - and how big the difference is on Djozz’ light meter…….
Provided good whether we could go outside (we have a nice beamshot area at a 5 min drive) and compare our GT’s to some other lights,
like my TN42 and modded Nitecore TM36 Light (dedomed XP G2 S2 with 849Kcd).