One has lots of fairly high reviews, the other has 1 good and 2 nasty ratings.
One has lots of tekkie info, other… not.
Several complaints about drawing much much less than the rated 36W.
Plus, if there’s one thing I learned from The Big Clive, it’s that identical-looking stuff on the outside can be drastically different on the inside. He did a comparison on something like 4 doodads (forget what they were), and only 1 was legit, whereas the others were shoddy to the point of being dangerous.
So in short, no idea.
Might just have to buy one/both and test test test. Keep the good, return the crap.