In my old Cavalier (RIP), I think I got 12yrs or more just from the come-with AC-Delco battery.
After that, I pretty much just bought boneyard batteries and milked them for 4-5yrs or so, each. Never a problem starting. After running even a short time, a fractional-second “crank” would start it right up. From a cold start, like overnight, about 1-2sec or so max.
That little donk had 9.3:1 compression, too.
Then again, I stuck on the biggest alternator I could. 78A? Only the 105A was bigger, but even then was available only with something like the cold-weather package from the factory. Only aftermarket racing-type alternators (Pro-Master, etc.) would have more oomf. Then again, they’d fit where a standard 12SI would fit, but mine had a slightly different mounting-ear, so couldn’t go that particular route.
It’d always kick out 14.5V except when heavily loaded. An “in-warranty” alternator I got was the smaller 65A alternator, and that’d start out at 14.5V for a few min, then drop down to the customary 13.8V when it’d heat up. Think that was the first time I had battery woes.
Someone mentioned to me that big rigs go through batteries every 2-3yrs or so! Dunno if that’s true, but the “secret” to longevity was to keep them as fully charged as possible. And from my own personal experiences, that seems true.
Someone who “did something” to his rig, tweaked up the alternator voltage or something, installed a second alternator, forgot what it was, claimed that he could then get 5-7yrs instead, doubling his usual battery-life.
—
For the record, I had a 0-5V (1mA@5V) analog meter with a scale of 10V-15V. Perfect! 9.6V zener diode in series with a regular 1N4004 dropped an almost perfect 5.0V (drop was only about ~0.5V @ 1mA). Aluminum box, lighter-plug, 24/7 voltmeter! So I could see in realtime down to a tenth-volt what the rails voltage was.