Best AA Batteries for Everyday Use—Duracell or Amazon Basics?
I am considering buying a pack of AA batteries to keep on hand for everyday devices, and I am deciding between Duracell Coppertop and Amazon Basics. What matters most to me is battery life, consistent performance, and cost per battery. I’d also like to avoid buying a large pack that isn’t worthwhile for occasional use.
These are the two options I’m considering: Affiliate disclosure: I may earn a commission from purchases through these links. [sb56637 removed affiliate links.]
Duracell Coppertop AA Batteries https://www.amazon.com/Duracell-Coppertop-AA-Ingredients-Long-lasting/dp/B0035LCFNQ
Both seem worth considering, but I’m unsure which would make more sense for general household use. If Duracell costs more per battery, does the difference in runtime justify it in your experience?
Has anyone used both brands in the same device? I’d appreciate comparisons in things like remotes, wireless mice, or battery-powered toys, since the device probably affects the results. Have you noticed inconsistent battery life, leakage, or any other drawbacks with either?
Would you buy either again, or is another option worth considering at a similar price?
Where possible use LSD (Low Self Discharge) NiMh, these are often branded as “ready to use” or “precharged” or similar.
The AA IKEA LADDAs represent good value, Eneloop is king for lifecycle longevity, but costs slightly more.
NiMh typically won’t leak and ruin your devices.
At higher currents (300ma+), NiMh can provide more energy to the device, at very low currents (analogue clocks) Alkaline cells have capacity, but obviously have the risk of leaking.
For long term “fit and forget” standby or storage, energizer lithium is best.
Not all devices work well on slightly lower voltage of NiMh, the graphs show that NiMh actually holds voltage better but in my experience, some devices (particularly older ones) seem to work better with Alkaline cells.
The data is a little old, but really no significant improvements have been made to battery chemistry, so the discharge profiles for alkaline Vs Lithium Vs NiMh still stand:
Since they hold 80% of their charge after 3 years in a drawer, to me they are just about the same as alkaline batteries, meaning you can think of them as just regular AA batteries rather than the old style rechargeables that needed frequent recharging, the bonus is that they don’t leak and are reusable for many many years.
I won’t touch an alkaline cell with a 10-foot pole. Lots of things have been ruined by alkaleaks. Disposable batteries are only for extremely rare use cases (Lithium primaries for low temperatures) or for really old people who still have the “boomer” single use mindset.
100% agreed, most of my cells are 4.2v lithium or NiMH, I’ve very few alkaline cells kept on hand for rare devices that are badly designed and don’t work well with Alkalines.
I personally keep some alkaline on hand (not installed) for when I expect to go on a daytrip 2+ hours drive from home. I figure a 2+ hour drive might entail a 5-8 hour wait for a tow during a critical breakdown on a major highway, and worst case scenario a 20ish hour trip home by foot. Backup NiMH would be nice in that case, which I do carry, but if for whatever reason I need to run them down, I’d rather abuse the alkalines which I wouldn’t mind throwing away.
Long story short, in this era of plenty, I’ve BEEN hungry before…and as a flashaholic, it’s a bad look when things run out of juice..it’s not a good feeling when either happens.
Let’s call alkalines a trauma concessioncompromise, lol
I don’t use alkaleaks.
A general rule of thumb is…
Only put alkaleaks in things that you don’t care about (or in devices that won’t accept nice LSD cells.)
Duracells and kirklands both purchased from octsoC are very similar, with the kirkland ones leaking much less frequently than the duracell, but the duracell lasting a tad longer under load. Personally, I think I may have had ONE kirkland leak, but that’s because I was doing a short test on a vampired cell…I “needed” to know if a “dead” (0.8V rested) cell could effectively still function as a “prison lighter.” And suprisingly, yes, yes it can. It just takes much longer to ignite the chewing gum wrapper “wick”.
I got, I think, a 24 pack of Kirkland AAA cells. After about a year sitting on a shelf in a cool maybe 65 to 72 degrees F or 18 to 22 defrees C) dry (maybe 25 to 45% RH) location, without being used, I noticed several leaking. I pitched them. In another 6 months, all of them showed leakage. I never got to actually use any of them. Yeah, anecdotal, but enough to make me not want to buy more.
I won’t use Duraleaks in anything period. All alkalines will leak eventually so I don’t store them in a device unless I use it frequently and thus keep fresh cells in it. I keep some on hand for giveaways and convenience but prefer rechargeable for regular use and Energizer Lithium primaries for non-rechargeable storage.
BTW this was taken today… To be fair the use by date was 12-25. But no telling how long they have been like this. Bottom line, I wouldn’t want to leave them in anything I wanted to continue to use for any length of time.
Alkaleaks are total shiite. You can get cheepie PKcell or EBL NiMH cells for the same price per cell as alkaleaks. And they won’t crap the bed and ruin whatever they’re in.
If 1.2V per cell isn’t digested well by the device, get 1.5V Li cells. Chicnod, Tenavolt, Xtar, they all work great.