If you have the coin, try to find an older Elzetta Bravo. Everything about them is tough, and the weakest points are probably the batteries, the clicky switch, and the lens, in that order.
For general EDC, you could always get him an Emisar d3AA or wait for the Kr1AA to come out.
If you just want something more basic, you could get him some kind of Streamlight.
I was in the same situation to select a light for a KY State Trooper graduate. He suggested a Streamlight. I looked at all the usual suspects and bought the Streamlight he chose.
There seems to be a strong, undeclared preference for & standardization on Streamlight lights for LEO’s. Their warranty is second to none. More importantly, an Officer would be well served to be able to pick up any light from any other LEO in any threatening situation and have an identical UI without needless fiddling.
We all know that there are likely ‘better’ lights. When it comes to safety at a moments notice, a familiar, reliable standard is more desirable for a LEO / 1st. Responder than the n-th. degree of performance & complex UI.
Good post…it’s due to standardization, seamlessness & cost control that most agencies have a definite requirement for their officers to carry & use department-issued duty flashlights, typically from Streamlight and Surefire.
These same agencies typically provide all the CR123 cells needed, which would otherwise become a burdensome cost to shoulder for officers on relatively low salaries.
Streamlight, it’s bright enough and very damage resistant. Before I retired from the Sheriff’s dept I carried the Mateminco TK01. It did everything I needed and was generally bullet-proof. Since then Streamlight has caught up. We need on/off with a few modes. Playing with the flashlight and mode rotation is the last thing needed when other things have our full attention.
Couple LEOs I know carried the Streamlight as duty unit and kept preferred light in pocket for backup.
Buddy Don said you don’t want to the dork without what everyone else is using and the fact they are assembled in Phonexville, PA USA goes a long way.
Phonexville’s claim to fame is this;
The 1958 Steve McQueen Blob movie filmed there.
Now they have this festival every year.